[per4ever]

If it's based on true talent there's no way Venus would be below justine, or Kim.

Justine is considered as the biggest talent in tennis these days..may be even in history. Consider only tennistalent and Justine is #1

 

[per4ever]

No, Venus and Serena do things no one else can do. Henin is talented, but her backhand is the only shot that people go gaga over. One handed backhands will always look more beautiful aesthetically than a two-handed backhand.

By the way I think Justine is third best, but this year she has been the second best at winning slams, and beating top players. Kim is #4 because beating the top four these days is a struggle for her. Serena is 1 and Venus is 2.

The williams sisters have other talents..more on the physical part of tennis imo. Of course they have tennistalent or they wouldn't be topplayers I'm just talking about real tennistalent..the touch of a player, subtility, control over the racket. I think Justine is number 1 on that part

btw I voted Justine third best. I think the ranking is always a good reflexion of the situation at the moment.

 

[per4ever]

Funny I can only think of the slice backhand, and sliding on clay as something justine does better than Venus.

I think you never saw Justine's volleys then.