[cherboy]

Or is she better than all of them?

 

[Pump-it-UP]

Better in terms of peak vs peak, or accomplishments? Maria's still less accomplished than all of them.

 

[The Kaz]

All of them.

 

[Mistress of Evil]

All of Them + PEAK PIERCE

 

[doomsday]

NOONE, this is Maria and Maria fans' day. Get out.

 

[ziros]

I'm a big fan of Maria,but I still have to say all of them for sure. But Maria still has time

 

[bobito]

All except possibly Hingis. That said, we don't know yet what more Sharapova may achieve.

 

[sdch]

King won a career slam!

 

[DragonFlame]

All 5 of those are better. Though she's got a nice shot to surpass hingis.

 

[Alejandrawrrr]

With her emphatic triumph over Errani she just put them all to shame

 

[sdch]

All except possibly Hingis. That said, we don't know yet what more Sharapova may achieve.

Possibly Hingis? Care to explain how?

 

[Joelina]

so jealous that all these 5 never won career slam :lol::lol:

i am just enjoying this moment, Maria

 

[Halepsova]

NOONE, this is Maria and Maria fans' day. Get out.

This thread hasn't moved to player forum yet.

 

[chirag]

Henin is so much better

 

[Grigorpova]

For now, all of them but in the future some may fall below.

 

[sdch]

so jealous that all these 5 never won career slam :lol::lol:

i am just enjoying this moment, Maria

I don't see how anyone is jealous. And the ignorance here is astounding. I never liked BJK, but give her credit - she won a career slam.

 

[justineheninfan]

At this point she is still below all of them. However I expect her to reach atleast 6 slams and surpass Hingis. Even with 5 slams she probably passes Hingis based on WAY superior longevity, coming from a career threatening injury whereas Hingis threw in the towel with a little foot injury, and the career slam.

 

[QINWEN-GOAT]

I created this poll already

it should be multiple choice

 

[Halepsova]

People will still remember she completed her career slam by beating scrub in the final. While Seles lost to GOAT Graf and Henin to Mauresmo, Venus to Serena and so on.

 

[NashaMasha]

The question is too controvercial. If who achieved more? than answer is ALL , except Hingis who is on the level of Sharapova.....

as for the question "Which non-career-slam-winners are better than Sharapova" it more implies discussion who is more universal and all surfaces master ....... In this case Masha is better than some in this list