Tennis Forum banner
21 - 35 of 35 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
6,688 Posts
"He says it's a good thing she lost, it's better for her preparation of the USopen"
=====

Yeah right, nothing like a real good loss to a way under ranked player in the first round in a match just before the U.S. Open.

A real momentum builder, eh? :rolleyes:
 

· Registered
Joined
·
12,908 Posts
If they were already hoping she would lose early then why not withdraw? She has enough money to pay if there is a fine! It wont benefit at all to play when shes already tired! Its better to withdraw than give a half assed effort.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,301 Posts
Experimentee said:
If they were already hoping she would lose early then why not withdraw? She has enough money to pay if there is a fine! It wont benefit at all to play when shes already tired! Its better to withdraw than give a half assed effort.
Kim herself really wanted to play, as she had commited herself before, and didn't want to dissapoint anyone. Parents and coach never liked it too much but Kim did have it her way, only to find out she really was running out of gas.

I'm still sure the tournament was quite happy she did play two matches, and all the fuss about having the new #1 in Toronto certainly didn't hurt the tournament in the end.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
6,631 Posts
somthing she will have to learn to do. i don't think she has ever seen the "physical" capability of her body. now she has. so in the future, i think she will be quick to no when to pull out of the tournies, and when not to. personally after five weeks in a row, you think the lightbulb would've went off.

i still say its the fact, that everyone is talking about the only and again only reason why she became number 1 was b/c of the fact that physically she is able to play so much and continue to win. the gurl isn't immortal. like we had to find out with serena from comments made about her. so it did look bad for kim to say that she just ran out of batteries. and have the week before this gurl that can play all the time and keep getting to semis and finals. i've always questioned her play coming up to the usopen. i still question it during the usopen. i don't even think she will get to the semis. its sad that Serena is out, cuz i really wanted venus at nuber 5, and in kim's quarters. kim hasn't had to prove herself. as in like Serena with Jennifer in the quarters, justine in the semis and then venus in the finals. or at the french, amelie quarters, justine semis, and had she won, kim would've been waiting. kim hasn't had to do that yet, so when it comes, it will be interesting to see how she fares having to take out at least 2 top 10 players, instead of just 1 in a tournie :)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,619 Posts
Kim and her coach are two different people. Just because he believes one thing doesn't mean Kim will agree or do everything he tells her to. So I don't think there's any huge conundrum there.

IMO, Kim made the wrong decision to play, but the thought of disappointing all those lovely Canadian tennis fans probably made her reconsider. It was a foolhardy act of matyrdom, and I hope she did learn her lesson from overexerting herself.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,619 Posts
TeeRexx said:
"He says it's a good thing she lost, it's better for her preparation of the USopen"
=====

Yeah right, nothing like a real good loss to a way under ranked player in the first round in a match just before the U.S. Open.

A real momentum builder, eh? :rolleyes:
I don't think his comments mean what you are hoping it to mean. He's not thinking of the match when he says he's glad she lost, he's thinking of her health, glad that she's out of the tournament and able to rest. The momentum was already built. She didn't need another tournament to play. And it wasn't a first round match, nor is Lina Krasnoroutskaya a "way under ranked player".
 

· Registered
Joined
·
839 Posts
vs1 said:
I think that Kim takes her commitments seriously. She had committed to play there and she honoured it. I am not saying that she tanked and lost on purpose. Of course not. But she probably wasn't as motivated...and having secured the #1 ranking and having the US Open approaching...she was probably also a little relieved that she now had a few extra days to rest. So I think that it affected her motivation. But she showed up because she SAID she was going to show up. And with all of the seeds withdrawing because of injuries, she probably also felt a bit more obligation from the tournament. They couldn't afford ANOTHER contender pulling out. For crying out loud, this is a Tier I event!!!
I agree 100% with your comments.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,880 Posts
as others have said Kim was just not as motivated to win and Lina played great - I think kim will still do well at the USOpen Theres always going to be a surprise quaterfinalist since I doubt Hantuchova is going to live up to her seedings(come on mary Pierce and Elena Bovina!)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
7,034 Posts
vs1 said:
I think that Kim takes her commitments seriously. She had committed to play there and she honoured it. I am not saying that she tanked and lost on purpose. Of course not. But she probably wasn't as motivated...and having secured the #1 ranking and having the US Open approaching...she was probably also a little relieved that she now had a few extra days to rest. So I think that it affected her motivation. But she showed up because she SAID she was going to show up. And with all of the seeds withdrawing because of injuries, she probably also felt a bit more obligation from the tournament. They couldn't afford ANOTHER contender pulling out. For crying out loud, this is a Tier I event!!!
I totally agree. I think this is exactly why she played. I'm sure Allaster appreciated it very much. I appreciated it too ;) the Rogers was my only chance to see Kim play..so although she would have been better off resting..I'm definatly glad she came :D

btw for the record..I think if she was going to skip a tournie she should have skipped LA.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
8,951 Posts
Kim felt obligated to the tour, especially after the ranking "system" helped to make her number one, on the strength of her playing twice the number of tournies as the former number one; now she's gonna pull out cause she's tired. Not likely. Plus I think the trip from Cali to Canada put her in the triple platinum miles club.


Seriously It wouldn't have looked good for the WTA for the new number one to pull out.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,949 Posts
Discussion Starter · #34 ·
DA FOREHAND said:
Seriously It wouldn't have looked good for the WTA for the new number one to pull out.
I really don't think anyone (except for people who know nothing 'bout tennis or people who just think from a commercial perspective) would have blamed her for not wanting to play 5 weeks in a row.

And if people did bother she shouldn't care especially after what she has been through last year with her shoulder injury (mainly because of playing too much in singles and doubles)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,055 Posts
Bull Crap.. If Kim was in the final today no one would have anything to say.. I mean, come on, she whipped the floor with her 3nd round opponent
 
21 - 35 of 35 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top