speculate

I say Jen.

...Jennifer, obviously...

really? Kim defeated Jenn at the final of Stanford and Kim doesn't normally fall to anyone who's name is not Serena, Venus, or Justine at a final of any tournament.

Yeah, i think that Kim would have won the title if she was facing Jen....Jen just can´t beat higher ranked players anymore. Of course she would have beaten Justine, but Justine ain´t a true hardcourt player.

Jennifer!!!!!!!!!!! in straight sets.

jomomma

Interesting question, it would all really depend on Kim's nerves - I think that JenCap would have come out firing from the start.

I'd speculate that it would be Kim to win but I wouldn't have been that surprised at all if it had been JenCap.

Kim in 3 sets !
Because Serena, Justine and Venus are almost the only ones who have a way of playing that really disturbs Kim!
And Capriati has the habit of choking at the end against the best players !

jenn, but it may have also been kim, coz henin would have worn down jenn in the semis

kim, cause bar her hiccup at montreal, the only players she has lost to this year are serena, venus and justine.

at least i think so

Jen now would be US Open-Champion!!!

Kimmy

i think kim in 2 tough sets

i don't think jen would have the stamina and kim has beaten jenn the last 3 times they met

bandabou how is justine not really a hard court player - she proved she is she didnt lose a match on it all summer!

Kim would have won. She owns Jen now, while if Justine had got through she beat Kim since Justine owns Kim now. Also I dont think Jen has the stamina that Justine has, and even if Jen had gotten into a winning position, she would have choked like she did against Justine, and Kim isnt a good player to choke against as shes great from behind.

really? Kim defeated Jenn at the final of Stanford and Kim doesn't normally fall to anyone who's name is not Serena, Venus, or Justine at a final of any tournament.

Click to expand...

Unless your name is Ai Sugiyama and you should be dead tired punch drunk-way too tired to win a final.

I'm convinced Clijsters would have found a way to choke. We'll never know of course, but until Kimmie wins one I'd have put money on Jennifer.