Tennis Forum banner

1 - 15 of 15 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,374 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Rate these players, Amelie Mauresmo, Justine Henin, Mary Pierce, Iroda Tulyaganova, Martina Hingis and Serena Williams?

My opinion:

1. Serena Williams<br />2. Mary Pierce<br />3. Martina Hingis<br />4. Justine Henin<br />5. Iroda Tulyaganova<br />6. Amelie Mauresmo <img src="tongue.gif" border="0"> <img src="tongue.gif" border="0">
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,115 Posts
1.Serena<br />2.Mary<br />3.Amelie<br />4.Juju<br />5.Martina<br />6.Iroda
 

·
Mean Admin Machine, Admeanistrator
Joined
·
36,597 Posts
Martina Hingis - when she's mentally in shape of course<br />Serena Williams<br />Justine Henin<br />Amelie Mauresmo<br />Mary Pierce<br />Iroda Tulyaganova
 

·
Moderator - Juniors
Joined
·
13,466 Posts
Serena Williams<br />Mary Pierce<br />Amelie Mauresmo<br />Martina Hingis<br />Justine Henin<br />Iroda Tulyaganova
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15,719 Posts
1. Serena Williams<br />2. Martina Hingis<br />3. Mary Pierce <br />4. Amelie Mauresmo <br />5. Justine Henin <br />6. Iroda Tulyaganova
 

·
Team WTAworld, Senior Member
Joined
·
20,610 Posts
1.Serena<br />2.Mary<br />3.Amelie<br />4.Iroda <br />5.Martina<br />6.Juju
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,495 Posts
1. Martina ( 5 GS, what proof do u want?)<br />2. Mary <br />3. Amelie<br />4. Serena<br />5. Juju

20. Iroda ( what is she doing in this list?)
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
63,516 Posts
Mary Pierce<br />Serena Williams<br />Martina Hingis<br />Amelie Mauresmo<br />Iroda Tulyaganova<br />Justine Henin
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,635 Posts
Serena Williams
Amelie Mauresmo
Mary Pierce
Martina Hingis
Justine Henin
Iroda Tulaganova
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,951 Posts
1. Serena Williams<br />2. Martina Hingis<br />3. Amelie Mauresmo<br />4. Justine Henin<br />5. Mary Pierce<br />6. Iroda Tulyaganova
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
27,114 Posts
1. Serena Williams<br />2. Martina Hingis<br />3. Mary Pierce<br />4. Amelie Mauresmo <br />5. Justine Henin<br />6. Iroda Tulyaganova
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,843 Posts
Assuming you mean physically AND mentally in shape, i.e. fully healthy and no Amelie-at-RG style meltdowns...

1. Mary Pierce. We've all seen what's happened to the opposition when Mary is 'on' in a tournament. She steamrollers them. Remember Hilton Head, um (was it 2000?). Winning most matches 6-1 6-1 - againts opposition like Seles, ASV etc. She's flattened everyone before, double-bagelled Hingis, and I'm putting her before Serena because she's done it to Serena too. A pity she's hardly ever in top physical/mental shape - it only happens a couple of times each year...<br />2. Serena Williams. Basically because she has the game, and her only weaknesses are her a) health and b) mental weaknesses.<br />3. Justine Henin. Again, in terms of weaknesses it's really just mental with her; if she plays a match nerve-free, she'd play better than any of us have ever seen her play. Unfortunately, as with Mary, this happens very rarely.<br />4. Amelie Mauresmo. Very close to Justine... but I think Justine's game is more refined, and the backhand slightly more exquisite.<br />5. Martina Hingis. She'd be faring a lot better at Slams if she was in top mental shape - i.e. realised that attempting to overpower the Big Babes is just not going to work, and mixing it up for them. I'm not convinced that she'd be able to beat any of the above if they were on top form though. The second serve is too much of a liability.<br />6. Iroda Tulyaganova. Right now, we've not seen her play enough to make a judgment. She's had some great results - thrashing Clijsters, Dementieva, Henin - but I'm not sure whether her terrible results - the American hard-court season - were due to a mental lapse or innate weaknesses in her game. In about a year's time, we should be able to rank her properly, and I'm guessing she'd be higher. Queenlindsay, I don't like your attitude towards her. She's in this list because a) m_pierce fan thought she should be, and b) because she's a fine, talented player who has proved on numerous occasions that she can beat the best, and beat them well.
 
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Top