[roooobert]

It's obvious that Momo's game isn't enough to be categorized as one of the best palyers. When serena, Henin, Davenport make good matches they win. When Momo does that there are still a lot of players that have a chance to beat her.

Okey, Momo is no.1 at the ranking, but that would be the case for a several players if they played every single week.

Just because Momo won a grand slam you cannot forget that she hasn't been a winner. Now she had a lot of luck in the aus, but I think it's wrong to think that just because of that victory she now can play unbelievable, without nerves and win over players she hasn't had a chance on before, for examle davenport and serena.

Momo is a good player, but she will never become the best. Well, if you ask her fans of course she is the best, she is ranked no.1.

 

[hablo]

Momo isn't even no.1 yet :spit:

I'm too lazy to look up and post her career stats for you ...

maybe you should though www.wtatour.com

Okey, Momo is no.1 at the ranking, but that would be the case for a several players if they played every single week.

Just because Momo won a grand slam you cannot forget that she hasn't been a winner.

 

[DragonFlame]

duh we everyone knew that, some people just got caried away
i myself am looking forward for some meetings between lindsay, amelie justine, maria, venus and a healthy kim to see where amelie actually stands in the hierarchy

 

[Carmen Mairena]

:retard: :retard: :retard:

 

[hablo]

i myself am looking forward for some meetings between lindsay, amelie justine, maria, venus and a healthy kim to see where amelie actually stands in the hierarchy

Likewise (you forgot to mention Serena though :tape: )

 

[FrenchY52]

Can't Amélie lose matches, like everybody ?

 

[DragonFlame]

Likewise (you forgot to mention Serena though :tape: )

exactly, we all need to see some matches between these players to be sure of what's going on and who's the best. yeah ok i forgot serena, maybe because i lost faith of her returning to the tour in the upcoming months(i don't mean this in any offensive way cause i would like her back on tour for sure! )

 

[suzie]

Can't Amélie lose matches, like everybody ?

Didn't you know she can't??? what next, what will you ask next?? Federer losing to Nadal??

 

[timafi]

 

[alibaby]

once more,a dumb and unneeded thread here! why cant you just enjoy a very good match,guys??without putting someone down??i knew,this talk would come up after that win,and it fills me with anger so much!! fact is,that amelie played just as well today as she played the whole week,no injuries,no nerves,absolutely fit! rather the opposite,nadia IMPROVED her nerves!and she lost fair and square to nadia today,who was up to the same level!!even that bit better,to be honest.so why is amelie talked into negativity now(and as a chain-reaction,nadias win gets devalued!)??WHY??you dont win a slam for nothing,no matter,HOW you win the matches.and she deserves her slam!!and she IS in the same league as all the others there,no matter,what you all say!so please,for the sake of sportsmanship,stay fair after a defeat...
thx

 

[SAEKeithSerena]

i'm sure that players aren't too thrilled to be playing her, so i would say she strikes some fear. she's clearly the best player this year so far.

 

[lolo21]

despite all the improvment Amelie has made in term of mental toughness ,i think there are still a few flaws in her game,the main being for me her forehand again......i really think she should do something to improve that shot if she wants to achieve more great things in the future
and i'm not saying that now because she just lost to Petrova.....i've already said the same thing just after her win in the AO.

 

[anlavalle]

once more,a dumb and unneeded thread here! why cant you just enjoy a very good match,guys??without putting someone down??i knew,this talk would come up after that win,and it fills me with anger so much!! fact is,that amelie played just as well today as she played the whole week,no injuries,no nerves,absolutely fit! rather the opposite,nadia IMPROVED her nerves!and she lost fair and square to nadia today,who was up to the same level!!even that bit better,to be honest.so why is amelie talked into negativity now(and as a chain-reaction,nadias win gets devalued!)??WHY??you dont win a slam for nothing,no matter,HOW you win the matches.and she deserves her slam!!and she IS in the same league as all the others there,no matter,what you all say!so please,for the sake of sportsmanship,stay fair after a defeat...
thx

totally agree with you. I´m already sick of this kind of threads

 

[pav]

I stiffen with fear
every time that I see her

 

[Volcana]

It's obvious that Momo's game isn't enough to be categorized as one of the best palyers. When serena, Henin, Davenport make good matches they win. When Momo does that there are still a lot of players that have a chance to beat her.

Okey, Momo is no.1 at the ranking, but that would be the case for a several players if they played every single week.

In some ways, that's the point. Who among the other current GS champs CAN play every week? Clijsters, Henin-Hardenne and Venus are all injury prone. As people were VERY fond of saying comparing Hingis to Venus and Serena at the turn of the century, a player also has to be able to stay on the court.

Also, Mauresmo is only carrying 20 tournaments. She doesn't owe her ranking to quantity. She's ranked #2 because she's the reigning champ at OZ, the YEC and Rome plus three Tier II's in the last 12 months.

 

[Brooks.]

Likewise (you forgot to mention Serena though :tape: )

9-1 :devil:

 

[Wsisters45]

For Capriati and Myskina,she sure as hell is a player to fear :tape:

 

[Mother_Marjorie]

Clijsters, Henin-Hardenne and Venus are all injury prone.

Not true. Henin-Hardenne is more illness prone than injury.

 

[SvetaPleaseWin.]

It's obvious that Momo's game isn't enough to be categorized as one of the best palyers. When serena, Henin, Davenport make good matches they win. When Momo does that there are still a lot of players that have a chance to beat her.

Okey, Momo is no.1 at the ranking, but that would be the case for a several players if they played every single week.

Just because Momo won a grand slam you cannot forget that she hasn't been a winner. Now she had a lot of luck in the aus, but I think it's wrong to think that just because of that victory she now can play unbelievable, without nerves and win over players she hasn't had a chance on before, for examle davenport and serena.

Momo is a good player, but she will never become the best. Well, if you ask her fans of course she is the best, she is ranked no.1.

i agree that mauresmo isn't as good as serena, venus, henin etc. but she is one of the best and she does actually have one of the best all round games in tennis.
her serve and forehand aren't great but they're not bad enough to be taken apart by other players. i think her main problem is her tactics, a lot of the time she just picks the wrong way to play. ie when she played ivanovic she kept hitting it her forehand and today she didnt make petrova move enough.
i would like to see her more aggressive and drive her backhand more
i'm not a fan of mauresmo but give her the respect she deserves, yes she got lucky at the aussie with 3 retirements but her grand slam win was long overdue, it was nice to see her fulfil her talent

 

[hablo]

9-1 :devil:

That will all change this year ! :devil: