Tennis Forum banner

1 - 20 of 24 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,315 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Why in both polls on this board was Jennifer Capriati considered more likely to win the Semifinal? Yes, she put up a good fight and showed the whole never-say-die thing and yada yada. But she lost. And why the hell did the majority expect otherwise. You people are supposed to be the smart tennis fans. If this match had been held on November 1 of last year, Kim should have been the favourite. Now, picking Jen as the more likely winner just seems ridiculous.

Why pick a player who is currently the defending champion of nothing, ranked 7th in the world, and 25-10 since the US Open to beat the player who is:

Ranked 3rd in the world, on the verge of retaking 2nd, defending champion of 5 titles, and 52-8 since the US Open.

They've both proven they can play on Clay, so that's not it. What the hell is up?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
21,802 Posts
um it's just a net poll... wtf?

you could ask the same of the people who root/vote for qualifiers when they face a top ten player, especially Serena. I mean, come the hell on!

People, I for one, thought that Jen was on a roll and Kim didn't look THAT good on clay since this is her first red clay court tournament. :rolleyes:

I do like Kim over Jen but I wanted Jen to get the title since Kim already has some. Not that hard to comprehend, really.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,626 Posts
Some people just vote for their favourite player. Only people like me who don't care about either have the ability to be neutral ;)

(I voted for Kim)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
612 Posts
I'm sure Pam Shriver and MJ Fernandez voted for Kim. They've been worshiping her butt like crazy since last November. (Little secret: I have too, only when I'm not worshiping Venus')

Also, I think there is a big difference between who you think it's going to win it, and who you want it to win. I had all faith in Kim for this match, she is a well deserved number two player in the world :worship:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lien

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,315 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
Mad-About-Venus said:
I had all faith in Kim for this match, she is a well deserved number two player in the world :worship:
High praise from a Venus fan. :worship:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,369 Posts
disposablehero said:
Why in both polls on this board was Jennifer Capriati considered more likely to win the Semifinal? Yes, she put up a good fight and showed the whole never-say-die thing and yada yada. But she lost. And why the hell did the majority expect otherwise. You people are supposed to be the smart tennis fans. If this match had been held on November 1 of last year, Kim should have been the favourite. Now, picking Jen as the more likely winner just seems ridiculous.

Why pick a player who is currently the defending champion of nothing, ranked 7th in the world, and 25-10 since the US Open to beat the player who is:

Ranked 3rd in the world, on the verge of retaking 2nd, defending champion of 5 titles, and 52-8 since the US Open.

They've both proven they can play on Clay, so that's not it. What the hell is up?
also, Jennifer hasnt beaten a higher ranked player in 2 years

TWO YEARS!!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,971 Posts
This just means there were more jen than kim fans who voted.
Exactly, I didn't vote, and If I had I would have voted for Kim. Lots of other Kim fans probably didn't vote either and then factor in a lot of people probably voted for Capriati as they didn't want Kim to get back to #2.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
3,204 Posts
Jennifer lead Kim 3-0 in matches.

Jennifer lead Kim 3-0 in grandslam titles.

Even though Kim right now was playing better, she's the one who had to prove herself against Jennifer.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
21,802 Posts
I forgot to mention, I didn't want an all-belgian final. and I don't think anyone disputed Kim deserving her ranking... *whistles*.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28,582 Posts
eta psi said:
Heh... so you see, it goes both ways (I'm looking at that Serena-Kim thread, atm). Most people just root for their favourites...which makes me wonder what the hell the point in posting a poll is anyhow? I suppose that it's "fun" for some people...I've sort of made a habit of not reading half of them now, since they are rather redundant.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,315 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
selesrules said:
Jennifer lead Kim 3-0 in matches.

Jennifer lead Kim 3-0 in grandslam titles.

Even though Kim right now was playing better, she's the one who had to prove herself against Jennifer.
You are correct on both counts. However, both these things happened when Jen was still winning titles and before Kim became an absolute monster. Lindsay also has 3 Slams, and leads her head to head against Kim. A bright person would look at recent results and realize who to favour in that matchup.
 

·
Sabatini lover Forever
Joined
·
15,213 Posts
You can make an poll on Anna vs anybody and most fans will pick Anna, but are only wishes.
Kim right now is playing better than Jennifer, people forget Jennifer has not won a title since Aopen 2002, plus she has not been able to beat Davenport, Serena, Venus, Kim or Amelie in latest matches against them. Plus put the fact that she is been losing to lower ranked players does not help Jennifer either. So logically Kim was the huge favorite over Jenn in this match, no matter if Kim had never beaten her before.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
3,702 Posts
disposablehero said:
Why in both polls on this board was Jennifer Capriati considered more likely to win the Semifinal? Yes, she put up a good fight and showed the whole never-say-die thing and yada yada. But she lost. And why the hell did the majority expect otherwise. You people are supposed to be the smart tennis fans. If this match had been held on November 1 of last year, Kim should have been the favourite. Now, picking Jen as the more likely winner just seems ridiculous.

Why pick a player who is currently the defending champion of nothing, ranked 7th in the world, and 25-10 since the US Open to beat the player who is:

Ranked 3rd in the world, on the verge of retaking 2nd, defending champion of 5 titles, and 52-8 since the US Open.

They've both proven they can play on Clay, so that's not it. What the hell is up?
It's a simple answer if you think about it... everyone here is stupid except me.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
4,078 Posts
Hey, I would've favoured Kim, but the head2head and the Slam titles advantage could've also made a convincing argument for Jennifer. I can see why people (her fans) would vote for her (want her to win) but I can't see how you can get so riled up about it.
 
1 - 20 of 24 Posts
Top