[Queenpova]

I think she'd drop 5 games at best :spit:

WHAT A BEAST. Best player of all time.

 

[Sam L]

She would beat Graf for sure.

 

[Sammo]

Beat her 7-5 7-6

 

[JeMa]

We will never know.

 

[T-rex]

Serena would win. At this point you look foolish with any other answer.


Please take the time to look at the caliber of players she has beaten in the last 2 months. We are talking about non-competitive matches against the very best players in the world.


During this match I was actually thinking of other sports where one person has separated so much from the rest of the field. Its a very short list.

 

[plokploky]

I think the better question would be how would this serena fare against peak pierce?

 

[Queenpova]

This is peak serena. Forget about 2003

 

[Sam L]

We will never know.

We do know and the answer is Serena. The only thing we will never know is how good Monica Seles could've been if she wasn't stabbed.

 

[Smitten]

Only Peak Borz can beat Serena.

 

[Jimmie48]

Best player of all time.

Nope. We talk when she wins it all in one year..

 

[TheHangover]

with that serve she is untouchable by every woman past and present. i would like to see her on grass vs some grass mugs like volandri

 

[JustSayDet]

Serena would win. On clay Graf would stand a much better chance and could even win more often then she lost. Serena's serve is the best EVER in the women's game...against players from previous generations that trumps anything they are bringing to the match.

 

[Queenpova]

Nope. We talk when she wins it all in one year..

Please. This serena is obviously the best player of all time.

 

[morbidangle]

If the surface is clay, she loses, on grass she wins IMO. Toss up elsewhere...

 

[Sombrerero loco]

peak pierce still would destroy her
im just kidding. graf was so GOOD. i think many people here never saw her playing live so some opinions will be a bit :spit:

 

[Serena = GOAT]

Even I won't lower myself to this heat of the moment talk.

It's impossible to compare.

 

[cehowardrx7]

One thing for sure, nobody STABBED Serena's opponents so she could win as with Graf!!!

 

[babsi]

Put another way, if you put Steffi in this generation, she would have a better game. She had a great serve but she would have to be better and it would be. She said before that she wished she had a two-handed backhand and she would probably have that plus the slice as well.

She would be a better player.

That is why it is hard to compare different generations.

 

[azinna]

Sorry, but you have to factor in a knifing and consistently neutralizing slice. Phenomenal movement. Potent, varied serving. And world-class ability to transition from defense to point-ending offense. This is a mature Peak Serena working the percentages, so there would be plenty of chances for Steffi to extend rallies and make it a serious contest.

That's different from 2002 Wimbledon-US Open Serena, whose movement was so stellar that she frequently got into position to launch and hit line-seeking missiles. Graf would have no chance there.
....

 

[cehowardrx7]

I think the better question would be how would this serena fare against peak pierce?

And Seles, that would be a good comparison!!