Tennis Forum banner

1 - 20 of 1278 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
352 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

Roland Garros is there for the taking. Who can beat her if she's playing well? Possibly Kim, but that's about it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,396 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

Roland Garros is there for the taking. Who can beat her if she's playing well? Possibly Kim, but that's about it.
Do yo think she's going to play the same as in her first career? I am curious to see how her new FH on clay.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,107 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

I would love for Henin to meet Serena on the clay and for the French crowd to be as pro Henin as possible.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,107 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

Do yo think she's going to play the same as in her first career? I am curious to see how her new FH on clay.
This is why I can't wait to see her play on clay.
In the past, she played a clay court game, using the topspin, angles, dropshots on the clay and then transitioned to more aggressive game on grass/hard court.

I wonder if she'll do the same or just stick with the all out aggression.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,396 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

I would love for Henin to meet Serena on the clay and for the French crowd to be as pro Henin as possible.
Ju has big crowd support pretty much everywhere except maybe US. I went to AO this year, they cheered for her no matter who's her opponent. I miss Ju on clay.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,396 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

This is why I can't wait to see her play on clay.
In the past, she played a clay court game, using the topspin, angles, dropshots on the clay and then transitioned to more aggressive game on grass/hard court.

I wonder if she'll do the same or just stick with the all out aggression.
I think she will adjust for clay, one way or the other. I can see her finish point quickly even on clay but I still think she will play topspins, dropshots and angels.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
352 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

In the past, she played a clay court game, using the topspin, angles, dropshots on the clay and then transitioned to more aggressive game on grass/hard court.
Really? Watch the 2005 FO Final and see if there was no all-out aggression.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,107 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

Really? Watch the 2005 FO Final and see if there was no all-out aggression.
Mary Pierce didn't show up, so Henin could be as aggressive as she wanted.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
352 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

Mary Pierce didn't show up, so Henin could be as aggressive as she wanted.
Really? She just happened not to "show up"? End of story.

This is yer typical tennis "analysis". on these Forums by people who apparently don't actually play the game. One day players don't "show up" for some obscure reason. No need to ask why, or if perhaps what their opponent is doing might have something to do with it. That takes work and knowledge.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,107 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

Really? She just happened not to "show up"? End of story.

This is yer typical tennis "analysis". on these Forums by people who apparently don't actually play the game. One day players don't "show up" for some obscure reason. No need to ask why, or if perhaps what their opponent is doing might have something to do with it. That takes work and knowledge.
LOL!
I played juniors for YEARS and have spent tens of thousands of hours on tennis courts.

I was a hitting partner up until 4 yrs ago for 2 WTA pros. One is retired now (she never cracked the top 100), the other was involved in a very memorable match at RG (and made it to the top 100). I won't say who and I'll leave it at that.
I can confidently say I play tennis much better than 90% of this board.

Mary Pierce herself said , she was too relaxed for the final. She showed up not focused and if you do that against Henin in an RG final, well that's what you get.
It is no coincidence that, that match is the most aggressive she's been in an RG final.

I will take Mary Pierce's word over your analysis.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
352 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

LOL!
I played juniors for YEARS and have spent tens of thousands of hours on tennis courts.

I was a hitting partner up until 4 yrs ago for 2 WTA pros. One is retired now (she never cracked the top 100), the other was involved in a very memorable match at RG (and made it to the top 100). I won't say who and I'll leave it at that.
I can confidently say I play tennis much better than 90% of this board.

Mary Pierce herself said , she was too relaxed for the final. She showed up not focused and if you do that against Henin in an RG final, well that's what you get.
It is no coincidence that, that match is the most aggressive she's been in an RG final.

I will take Mary Pierce's word over your analysis.
Well, we'll take your word for your tennis prowess. It's just that the way you talk it doesn't sound like you have much practical experience. But then until high-speed photography came along tennis pros thought that on topspun shots they were turning the heads of their racquets over the ball as they hit it. Quite often, being able to do something doesn't entail knowledge of how you hit it. All of us can walk but do we know precisely how we do it?

As for Mary's sacrosanct word, I'm not quite sure why playing a Slam Final in front of your adopted country would make you "too relaxed" and therefore unable to cope with Justine's aggression.

But that's immaterial to the argument. You've said that Justine chooses to play more conservatively on clay. Yet this time she chose to play differently. Could it be that this is the way she wants to play and that when she's more passive it's because she's less confident?
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,107 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

Quite often, being able to do something doesn't entail knowledge of how you hit it. All of us can walk but do we know precisely how we do it?
I am in total agreement with you on this. My 1HBH is a natural shot and as such, I have a hard time teaching the 1HBH. I had to learn to hit a 2HBH from scratch so I can teach that easily. Same with the forehand, because I have had to work to build that shot.

You've said that Justine chooses to play more conservatively on clay. Yet this time she chose to play differently. Could it be that this is the way she wants to play and that when she's more passive it's because she's less confident?
It could very well be.
The thing is, most players play more conservatively on clay than they do on other surfaces. Average first serve speeds are slower at RG than at Wimbledon and US Open. There is use of more spin and being more consistent. It's no coincidence RG always has the fewest winners and aces of all the slams.
That's the way to win RG. However, most women play the same game on clay that they do on other surfaces so I believe Henin can be more aggressive and still win comfortably on clay.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
352 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

The thing is, most players play more conservatively on clay than they do on other surfaces. Average first serve speeds are slower at RG than at Wimbledon and US Open. There is use of more spin and being more consistent. It's no coincidence RG always has the fewest winners and aces of all the slams.
I think it's important to distinguish between speed through the air and speed off the court. It's the latter rather than the former that is responsible for the difference between court-surfaces (leaving aside variations in bounce due to worn surfaces). The reason clay is slower is because it comes off the court a lot slower than faster surfaces, not because of the speed through the air - which is the thing measured by the speedguns.

Some players temper their games because they think it's futile to crack the ball when the surface is going to slow it down but others may take the view that hitting it harder is the way to at least partially overcome this. I think Justine is likely to take the latter road.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,107 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

Some players temper their games because they think it's futile to crack the ball when the surface is going to slow it down
It is futile. Almost all ATP players do this. That's why the average first serve speed is slower at RG than at other slams.
The emphasis is more on the placement of the serve and less on the speed. It's the way I was taught to play on clay, (I still suck on the surface lol)
The surface negates the pace of your shot, giving your opponent just that bit more time to get to the ball. You will make more errors hitting harder, riskier shots but you won't benefit from putting pressure on your opponent because of the surface.

The gritty surface of clay causes more friction when the ball contacts the surface so it doesn't move through the court as much but the friction gives the ball more topspin than a regular hard court so it bounces higher. (I HATE playing on clay)

but others may take the view that hitting it harder is the way to at least partially overcome this. I think Justine is likely to take the latter road.
Very few are successful with that approach. In recent history, Agassi and Serena Williams are the only players I can think of to have been successful with a hit harder and flatter approach to RG.

Justine is a special case, given that of the current crop of WTA players only a handful are good on clay, so she should be able to succeed with whatever gamestyle she chooses.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,995 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

Perhaps Mary saying that she was too relaxed in the 05 FO final was an excuse for her one sided defeat? I think the Justine-Carlos game plan was to be agressive early to keep Mary from finding her groove. They knew that if Mary felt confident early she could keep Justine pinned behind the base line, which could give Mary the victory. Fortunately, Justine was on fire that day and her game play worked. Mary had a one dimensional game, therefore, by being agressive early Justine denied Mary her power game.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,603 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

It wasn't Carlos' plan actually. I remember Ju saying that she played that second week instinctively and not according to Carlos' plan. She described it as improvisation. And boy did it turn out well. That's the timing I want to see again, it was as good as in 2007, actually.

The 2005 final is possibly the best GS final she has played so far - nothing Pierce could do about it, she was struggling to win pts, let alone games.
 

·
Arnian, Prince of Justinedom
Joined
·
3,781 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

I never watched the 2006 final, how was it in terms of Justine's quality?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,978 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

I never watched the 2006 final, how was it in terms of Justine's quality?

The match was closer than the score indicated. Basically, Justine played very aggressively in the first 4 games and then tighten up while Kuz choked when she was ahead in the 2nd set.


:):):)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,978 Posts
Re: Justine's clay session - discussion thread

I am a bit concerned about the lack of news wrt her schedule. Maybe she has more physical problem so she is waiting to see how her body recovers before making any commitment.

:help::help::help:
 
1 - 20 of 1278 Posts
Top