[northern lad]

Yes because risk returns are the only reason I'm leading the tour. The excellent timing on my groundstrokes have nothing to with it. :lol: Banning R trigger returns wouldnt hurt me. My serve is huge so I would hardly lose a point on serve.

With risk returns breaks of serve would be scarce which is the exact opposite of womens tennis which is full of breaks. Those without big serves (Dementieva, Safin etc) would also be at a bigger disadvantage.

can someone remind me again why i chose a player with a weak serve and strong return when i can serve fairly well but can't time a return to save myself?

 

[F-R-E-A-K]

I never realised we could use the L trigger during rallies.

 

[youizahoe]

Notes to Carabrator :

New rule : No more trigger shots in rallies only on serve and return. Drop shots still allowed?

 

[Caralenko]

Urgh.

Well, I suppose Justin has a point in that there has to be some potential risk on a shot and the chance for it to go out... but we don't want any brainless L trigger bashers, really :lol: I think there is a good enough angle on a well timed Top Spin shot and it will land right at the corner.

Is anyone adamantly against allowing L triggers in rallies? I'm still on the fence personally.

 

[Justin SW]

I'd like the left trigger shots to be banned during the rallies

 

[northern lad]

i say leave them, at least for now. i haven't played with them up to this point, and i think i need to experiment with them before i say yay or nay.

 

[Justin SW]

not if we allow L Trigger shots :shrug:

I Was bad repped by Glenn for writing that :lol:

This.

 

[Andrew Laeddis]

Leave them

 

[Caralenko]

And why wouldn't drop shots be allowed? That would be like banning lobs. It's a legitimate tennis shot. If you can't get there, it's your problem not your opponent's.

 

[Maria Croft]

I say we ban all risk shots during a point, since I actually thought that was the rule in the first place.

I do agree though, using a risk shot would add realism to the game because you could make more errors, but that's just in theory. You can master the risk shot and never have it go out. Then there is no risk, that's just not how the real game works.

 

[GracefulVenus]

oh dear.

 

[Renalicious]

I say we don't ban L or R trigger shots. If not we should ban drop shots too. :smash: sw9

 

[youizahoe]

Drop shots aren't trigger shots. They don't need the left or right trigger to function.

 

[dynamoRockstarr]

Drop shots aren't trigger shots. They don't need the left or right trigger to function.

:yeah:

 

[Certinfy]

I say we play the way we want to play

 

[Justin SW]

No it just aint work that way

 

[youizahoe]

New thought :

Either allow serve & return trigger shots or rally trigger shots. But not both, it disadvantages more ppl than advantages