im not a big fan of kim but behind sugiyama? come on be realistic. she should be 4th imoVolcana said:Take the top ten (or eight, or six, or sixteen)
Now re-arrange them according to point building skill. You can't hold good serves against players, but it aces aren't 'built' points. Ties go to the higher ranked player, so if you aren't sure, assume the rankings have SOME validity. Don't go crazy. ALL top ten player build points better than ALL player ranked outside the top hundred.
Understand, this isn't a list of 'who's the best'. If you don't understand yourself how points are built, you're going to have a little trouble.
I'm not planning on heavy defense of my choices, this is too subjective, but here's my first take on the list.
00 Hingis - (Cause standards are nice)
04 V Williams
** I would have had Venus and Lindsay reverse on this list in past years. But Venus is constructing points better since its become obvious she can't beat Serena any other way. (Actually, that way hasn't worked either, but things are closer.) And Lindsay is not constructing points as well as she was three years ago, or finishing them off as well.
06 S Williams
** This might be kinda low for Serena, but her idea of 'opening up the court' is getting a six inch wide lane she can get the ball through. She does try to construct points, in the late round, vs her sister or Capriati or the Belgians. But against most players, it never becomes necessary to do more than move them back and forth along the baseline.
Note that Sugiyama and Myskina are ahead of Kim. 'How can that be?' You ask. Easy. Myskina, for example, knows what she's doing out there. She'll ATTEMPT to construct points, but it's virtually impossible for her to get a ball outside Kim's range. Kim can keep returning til she gets a ball she can put away.
Constructing points is just a skill. It's like having a good forehand. It won't win the tournament for you, but its nice to have.