Changes regarding Order of play - TennisForum.com
TennisForum.com   Wagerline.com MensTennisForums.com TennisUniverse.com
TennisForum.com is the premier Women's Tennis forum on the internet. Registered Users do not see the above ads.Please Register - It's Free!
Reply

Old May 20th, 2011, 11:21 AM   #1
country flag ma re
Senior Member
 
ma re's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 11,903
ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute
Changes regarding Order of play

Hy all

Due to a recent incident in Brussels, involving several OOP's posted by several players, it's time we specify the details of rules in regard to posting Order of play.

Without further dragging the story of who did what and who is to blame, I'll focus here only on the existing problem. So...

One suggestion (I think it was made by coolfish1103) was that we don't even post official OOP in the tipping thread of a tournament, and that we just let people find OOP for themselves. I don't think this is a good idea actually, for several reasons. First of all, some players are new to the forum and don't know much about tennis, so they could have a tough time finding trustworthy information (as this incident showed, even some tipping regulars can sometimes source incorrect information). Also, if every player would be forced to find daily OOP for him/herself, that would require additional work for the players, so many could lose interest in the game as doing this would take away more of their time. All in all, we have always posted OOP, and I think we should continue with that.

My suggestion is that for each tournament we establish not only the moderator/manager, but also the co-manager, someone who would help out the manager with things like the OOP. It would be someone chosen by the manager personally, and someone in whom he/she has enough trust of being able to do a good job.

We should also specify sources from which managers should take OOP's. My suggestion is quite obvious, that the mandatory source should be the WTA website, that the alternative source should be the tournament website, and that only if neither of those is accessible or has an OOP posted, the moderator should be allowed to choose where he gets it from.

Another idea that I have is that we establish a rule by which official OOP should always be posted on the first page of the thread (in a reserved post). Another OOP (provided by the co-manager) could be posted anywhere in the trhead, but the official one should always be in the same post, so that players can easily find it.

So, tell me what do you think about all this, wether you have some other ideas, should we do some things differently etc. Every idea will be open for discussion.

Take care and enjoy the game!
ma re is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 

Old May 20th, 2011, 11:29 AM   #2
country flag Håkon
Senior Member
 
Håkon's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Bonn, NRW
Posts: 17,622
Håkon has a reputation beyond repute Håkon has a reputation beyond repute Håkon has a reputation beyond repute Håkon has a reputation beyond repute Håkon has a reputation beyond repute Håkon has a reputation beyond repute Håkon has a reputation beyond repute Håkon has a reputation beyond repute Håkon has a reputation beyond repute Håkon has a reputation beyond repute Håkon has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

Quote:
Originally Posted by ma re View Post

One suggestion (I think it was made by coolfish1103) was that we don't even post official OOP in the tipping thread of a tournament, and that we just let people find OOP for themselves.
I think coolfish' suggestion was 'only the manager' posts OOP. Then at least we know who to blame. If you want to tip before the manager posts, then you need to find the OOP.

Sasja argued against that in the Brussel thread, saying that managers can't be online all the time and therefore it's easier if other people help out, but the counterargument is that OOPs can be corrected on websites and therefore you don't need to be online until say 1-2 hours after the OOP is posted, when we probably know it's correct. As long as you're online in the evening of the match that's probably ok - and if you can't then just give the responsibility to someone else - that'll be where your idea of a co-manager comes in I guess.

The source idea is also good. Maybe try to link when you source it, too, somewhat like this:

Quote:

OOP Friday (PDF)
Péng vs Zvonaryova
Wozniacki vs Schiavone
so people can check for themselves and scream if there's something wrong.

Oh, and ma re: thanks for always trying to make the game better
__________________
My twitter | FWTT: Cornelia du Preez
game wins: FITD US Open '12, Guangzhou '10 (#1 since 8 July 2013), TT Indian Wells '11, TT doubles Moskva '11, Brussel '12, Pattaya '13, Stuttgart '13 (w/Andreas), PAW 4 titles, Suicide Olympic gold + 2 titles, Tipping 3 titles (#1 for 25 weeks, USO Series '12), Q-Ball 7 titles, Blackjack #1 2012, Pentathlon #1 2012 (5 titles)
Азарэнка | Павлюченкова | Arvidsson| Halep | Eikeri | Clijsters | Rus | Van Uytvanck | Watson | Bertens | Superboerin Hogenkamp | Schoofs
Håkon is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 20th, 2011, 12:58 PM   #3
country flag Miracle Worker
Senior Member
 
Miracle Worker's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Universe
Posts: 24,431
Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute Miracle Worker has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Changes regarding Order of play



I think in almost every tournament we have special post for something like OOP - I use something like this, and I noticed that almost everyone use special post for OOP too. I agree with Sasja, that manager usually doesn't spend his/her all evening to check if new OOP is published. In normal conditions someone posts OOP, and it's enough (and manager later just confirms it). In my tournaments I didn't notice few extra OOPs.

I think that Brussels was bad exception. We can simply authorize few players to post OOP e.g. Sasja or Spain are usually very fast...
__________________
The Brainless Pusher
Ernests Gulbis, Marin Cilic, John Isner
Gilles Simon, Nicolas Almagro, Tommy Haas, Jack Sock
Kimiko Date Krumm, Tomas Berdych, Michail Youzhny, Daniel Brands
Elena Dementieva, Julia Cohen, Anna Chakvetadze
Miracle Worker is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 20th, 2011, 01:17 PM   #4
country flag ma re
Senior Member
 
ma re's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 11,903
ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

Or here's a crazy idea...actually it's not crazy at all and it would make the game much easier for the manager, as well as for the players. Manager simply just posts the entire draw of the tournament in one of the posts on the first page, and players send picks for the whole rounds. In case a change in the draw happens, the manager simply edits that post as soon as he/she can. In case a player wants to change one or more of his picks, he simply says that in an additional post. We count points on a day by day basis, like we did so far, eventhough people have posted for the entire round. Of course, manager edits the draw post after each round, so that people know the match-ups of the following round.

?!

Last edited by ma re : May 20th, 2011 at 04:04 PM.
ma re is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 20th, 2011, 03:55 PM   #5
country flag Sasja
Senior Member
 
Sasja's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 25,669
Sasja has a reputation beyond repute Sasja has a reputation beyond repute Sasja has a reputation beyond repute Sasja has a reputation beyond repute Sasja has a reputation beyond repute Sasja has a reputation beyond repute Sasja has a reputation beyond repute Sasja has a reputation beyond repute Sasja has a reputation beyond repute Sasja has a reputation beyond repute Sasja has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

I believe the "Brussel-OOP" was an incident, a little mistake. I can't remember we had any problems before. And ma re handled it very well Also it were only 2 1st round matches (2 points total) and no one benefit from this. It's just a game we play for fun. But I do think we should try and find a solution to prevent something like this from happening again.

I agree that posting the OOP on the 1st page of the thread is good. I know most of us do that anyway. For me personally I do it so people do not have to search for it.

If I'm running tournaments in Australia for example I wouldn't be able to post the OOP first because of the time difference, most likely I will still be sleeping at that time
An assistant manager would be good. Someone who can help out posting the OOP. If you don't think you can post the OOP for the next day early, you can ask in the tournament thread or PM him/her and ask to post the OOP.

Quote:
Originally Posted by ma re View Post
Or here a crazy idea...actually it's not crazy at all and it would make the game much easier for the manager, as well as for the players. Manager simply just posts the entire draw of the tournament in one of the posts on the first page, and players send picks for the whole rounds. In case a change in the draw happens, the manager simply edits that posts as soon as he/she can. In case a player wants to change one or more of his picks, he simply says that in an additional post. We count points on a day by day basis, like we did so far, eventhough people have posted for the entire round. Of course, manager edits the draw post after each round, so that people know the match-ups of the following round. ?!
This is not a crazy idea ma re I think it is a really good idea. Tipping per round instead of per day.
The only thing is that sometimes on Monday we have a few MD matches as well as final qualifying round.....or there have been tournaments when on a day the remaining 1st round matches will be played as well as some 2nd round matches. So not all 1st round winners are known.

Winners for 1st round matches with qualifiers can be picked on day 2. And if you change the thread title with "qualifiers have been placed" or something like that players can post picks for these matches on the next day. If we can solve when different rounds are played on the same day, this is good solution.

Also I think it's good, because some players sometimes forget to post their picks on a day. And with picking per round I think it will be easier for them.
__________________
BERTENS SHARAPOVA KVITOVA MUGURUZA GIORGI HAMPTON
SAFAROVA PAVLY KANEPI BARTHEL TOWNSEND KLEYBANOVA

DEL POTRO TSONGA MONFILS
LISICKI FLIPKENS MATTEK-SANDS ARVIDSSON KRAJICEK REZAI

Last edited by Sasja : May 20th, 2011 at 04:03 PM.
Sasja is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 20th, 2011, 11:08 PM   #6
country flag Payam
Senior Member
 
Payam's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 1,872
Payam is a splendid one to behold Payam is a splendid one to behold Payam is a splendid one to behold Payam is a splendid one to behold Payam is a splendid one to behold Payam is a splendid one to behold Payam is a splendid one to behold Payam is a splendid one to behold Payam is a splendid one to behold Payam is a splendid one to behold Payam is a splendid one to behold
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

I believe assistant manager would be a good idea and you can organize them according to the continents. For instance, I am in NZ and I can help with Auckland/AO and all the other tournaments in Australia. I think there are enough people all around the globe who are willing to help.
Payam is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 21st, 2011, 07:05 AM   #7
country flag ma re
Senior Member
 
ma re's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 11,903
ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

So far I have to say I like the tipping per round idea the best. So since I'm running RG, I'll do it like that but leave to players the choice of voting per round or per day. In other words, I will accept both ways, but I will only post (and update) the draw and leave it to people to find OOP themselves if they want to vote per day.
ma re is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 21st, 2011, 03:43 PM   #8
country flag ronim1
Senior Member
 
ronim1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 5,213
ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

When the whole tipping games started, it was per day, and believe me it was much worse than today.

As mentioned the problems happen usually first couple of days, as LL get into the MD, and not all Tipping players catch up upon those changes, thus placing the draw earlier, and than changing it is like like changing the OOPs.

I think we should keep this game as simple as possible.
The official post of the manager should be the one considered in any case of arguments.
If he/she will be able to update it on time, good, if not we'll won't take those matches into account.
It is the responsibility of the players to look for updates.
As tournaments are spread all over the world, sometimes players from the east will have it easier with the time, and other times from the west.
__________________
2013-Suicidee Tennis:Rank:56 Tipping: Rank: 8 Winner-AEGON Eastbourne;Carlsbad;Linz C-Y-P:Rank: 12 Winner-Florianopolis Pentathlon:Rank: 5 Winner-AUS Open;Florianopolis
2012- Tipping:Winner-Aus Open;London OG C-Y-P: Winner-Miami;Montreal Pentathlon:Winner-Stanford;London OG
2011- Tipping: Winner-Baku
2010- Tipping: Winner-Generali Ladies Linz;
2009 Winner Tipping:
Portoroz;2008 Winner Suicide Tennis: Generali Ladies Linz Tipping: Fortis Luxembourg;Kremlin Cup;Guangzhou;New Haven;OG Beijing;Los Angeles;Rome
ronim1 is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 21st, 2011, 04:25 PM   #9
country flag ma re
Senior Member
 
ma re's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 11,903
ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

Quote:
Originally Posted by ronim1 View Post
...thus placing the draw earlier, and than changing it is like like changing the OOPs.
I agree, that's why in Roland Garros, I'll post the draw, but I won't be modifying it, I'll just change it for every round. The only changes to the draw would be adding qualifiers once they are known (and at the time of this post they are already known). We already established that only the initial matches will count and not any that involve LL's (pre-match retirements/withdrawals) so there's no risk of problems in that regard. Let's consider this Roland Garros as an experiment and see how it goes. Will it be easier or harder for the players and for the manager. I really wanted to make sure that something similar to Brussels doesn't happen in Paris, so I had to decide as soon as possible, cause the play starts tomorrow and I didn't have a lot of time to do everything due to other "chores" (helping out in Brussels, updating the rankings...). Hope it all goes well.
ma re is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 21st, 2011, 05:57 PM   #10
country flag WhoAmI?
Senior Member
 
WhoAmI?'s Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 7,275
WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

I don't really like the idea of tipping a whole round at the time. There could be changes in the draw (withdrawal, placing the qualifiers etc), I know those are likely to happen in the beginning of the tournament, but still I don't want to check back and forth making the changes.

And also, some tournaments have a weird scheduling, where there are some 2nd round matches played earlier than some 1st round ones. In this case is definitely much easier to tip on daily bases, and is less confusing.

Besides, when I started this game, people found the OOPs themselves, if someone posted it in the game thread it was because they were nice.

So, I think manager should post the OOP in the first page of the thread, and update the thread title accordingly (example: Thursday's OOP in post #2). Until the manager hasn't posted the official OOP, players can find it for themselves and post their picks, but not the OOP.
WhoAmI? is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 21st, 2011, 06:08 PM   #11
country flag ma re
Senior Member
 
ma re's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 11,903
ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute ma re has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

Quote:
Originally Posted by WhoAmI? View Post
I don't really like the idea of tipping a whole round at the time. There could be changes in the draw (withdrawal, placing the qualifiers etc), I know those are likely to happen in the beginning of the tournament, but still I don't want to check back and forth making the changes.

You won't have to, because ONLY INITIAL MATCHES COUNT FOR POINTS. Matches where people witdraw etc. won't count.

And also, some tournaments have a weird scheduling, where there are some 2nd round matches played earlier than some 1st round ones. In this case is definitely much easier to tip on daily bases, and is less confusing.

If you tipp for the whole round, that's actually less confusing - you just post for the whole round and let the manager count points after each day.

Besides, when I started this game, people found the OOPs themselves, if someone posted it in the game thread it was because they were nice.

So, I think manager should post the OOP in the first page of the thread, and update the thread title accordingly (example: Thursday's OOP in post #2). Until the manager hasn't posted the official OOP, players can find it for themselves and post their picks, but not the OOP.
I can't afford another epic saga and mega drama like the one in Brussels, and I especially can't let it happen on a grand slam. Too much points is at stake. Several people pulled out of a tournament because of it and something obviously needed to be done to prevent it from happening again. Besides, I said I will only try it in Paris and we'll see how it goes. If many people protest during this tournament we'll probably go back to how things were before or include some changes to the "old way". Now we have two weeks to figure things out.
ma re is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 21st, 2011, 06:29 PM   #12
country flag WhoAmI?
Senior Member
 
WhoAmI?'s Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 7,275
WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute WhoAmI? has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

Quote:
And also, some tournaments have a weird scheduling, where there are some 2nd round matches played earlier than some 1st round ones. In this case is definitely much easier to tip on daily bases, and is less confusing.

If you tipp for the whole round, that's actually less confusing - you just post for the whole round and let the manager count points after each day.
Well, you see you can't possibly tip the whole round at once if the matches from different rounds happen in the same day. There still are some matches for the 2nd round, some for the 3rd round.

You can always link to WTA official site for OOP, or like I said have just the manager to post it.

It's very unfortunate what happened in Brussels, and I'm sorry for my mistake, I shouldn't have been so eager to post the OOP.

Good luck anyway.
WhoAmI? is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 21st, 2011, 07:12 PM   #13
country flag ronim1
Senior Member
 
ronim1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 5,213
ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of ronim1 has much to be proud of
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

I have no protest on who and to publish the OOP ( or draw).
I strongly am against tipping rounds instead of days, because this will make the scores and whole picture more complicated.

Let's enjoy RG.
__________________
2013-Suicidee Tennis:Rank:56 Tipping: Rank: 8 Winner-AEGON Eastbourne;Carlsbad;Linz C-Y-P:Rank: 12 Winner-Florianopolis Pentathlon:Rank: 5 Winner-AUS Open;Florianopolis
2012- Tipping:Winner-Aus Open;London OG C-Y-P: Winner-Miami;Montreal Pentathlon:Winner-Stanford;London OG
2011- Tipping: Winner-Baku
2010- Tipping: Winner-Generali Ladies Linz;
2009 Winner Tipping:
Portoroz;2008 Winner Suicide Tennis: Generali Ladies Linz Tipping: Fortis Luxembourg;Kremlin Cup;Guangzhou;New Haven;OG Beijing;Los Angeles;Rome
ronim1 is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 22nd, 2011, 02:54 AM   #14
country flag legionmx
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 342
legionmx is a name known to all legionmx is a name known to all legionmx is a name known to all legionmx is a name known to all legionmx is a name known to all legionmx is a name known to all legionmx is a name known to all legionmx is a name known to all legionmx is a name known to all legionmx is a name known to all legionmx is a name known to all
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

I think that the best solution is the most simple. As I already said in the Brussels thread, people should wait for a manager or co-manager to post the OOP, or tip under their own risk.

I think there you should be at least 3 persons authorized to post OOP's: the manager, a co-manager, and an official OOP poster. Either the manager can specifically ask the other two to fill in for him/her, or it could be established that the if no OOP is posted, any of them can post the official OOP. If posters that are not authorized to post OOPs want to post their tips, they could do so under their own risk, understanding that only the matches in the official OOP are going to be considered for points.

I feel ambiguous about the tip per round system. I think it is a good way for people who do not look up OOPs on their own to tip freely and not be bother with possibles changes. It is also a good way to have an early "official" knowing about which matches will be counted. In this way, it is a good safety net against things like the Brussels incident.

Having said that, I think the OOP system is better, and I will personally use the tip by day option.

I think ma re solution was good, in the way that it provides a safety net, and is a more flexible way to tip. I still think that the 'official OOP's posters' solution is the ideal one.
legionmx is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old May 22nd, 2011, 03:42 AM   #15
country flag BlackPanther.
Senior Member
 
BlackPanther.'s Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Posts: 5,393
BlackPanther. has a brilliant future BlackPanther. has a brilliant future BlackPanther. has a brilliant future BlackPanther. has a brilliant future BlackPanther. has a brilliant future BlackPanther. has a brilliant future BlackPanther. has a brilliant future BlackPanther. has a brilliant future BlackPanther. has a brilliant future BlackPanther. has a brilliant future BlackPanther. has a brilliant future
Re: Changes regarding Order of play

I'm agree with the manager and co-manager idea.
(Shame on me, I didn't notice any kind of problem with the OOP in Brussels)
__________________
BlackPanther. is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


Copyright (C) Verticalscope Inc
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
vBCredits v1.4 Copyright ©2007, PixelFX Studios