[Droolv]

1) 8.5 - Wow that is an amazing banner! Love the colouring, especially the blue in the sky. Fantastic font (birth of a hero?) and I like the white glow.

2) 8 - Another fantastic banner, again the effects are great. I like font (what is it called?) and it's positioned well. Excellent cropping and choice of picture.

[Maryamator]

Originally Posted by Sammy 4 eva!!!

Can you guys please rate these

1)

2)

3)

4)

5)

6)

Tips for how I can improve would be great

1- 10( I love the coloring)
2,3,4- 8
5-8 {IMO, it would be better without the heart in the begining)
6-7.

[Maryamator]

Originally Posted by droolv3

It's a game banner, but I really like it

Anyone's ratings or thought

i love it
9

[Sean.]

Originally Posted by droolv3

1) 8.5 - Wow that is an amazing banner! Love the colouring, especially the blue in the sky. Fantastic font (birth of a hero?) and I like the white glow.

2) 8 - Another fantastic banner, again the effects are great. I like font (what is it called?) and it's positioned well. Excellent cropping and choice of picture.

Yes the 1st is 'Birth of a Hero ' and the second is called 'Viner Hand ITC' Thanks for the rating

[Maryamator]

Originally Posted by 5ean

No that's great thanks. Exactly what the thread it for

How about these?

1)

2)

ilove them
9.

[Sammy 4 eva!!!]

Thanks guys Great thread BTW

[Poiree]

Originally Posted by Sammy 4 eva!!!

Can you guys please rate these

1)

2)

3)

4)

5)

6)

Tips for how I can improve would be great

7 for all of them (I love the coloring on all of them, but saving them as gif makes them look a bit worse than if they were saved as jpg or png )

[Poiree]

Originally Posted by droolv3

It's a game banner, but I really like it

Anyone's ratings or thought

9 really cool

Originally Posted by 5ean

No that's great thanks. Exactly what the thread it for

How about these?

1)

2)

9

7 (no special complaint. It's just too simple)

[Poiree]

Originally Posted by Pebbles

Ok, this is my first ever attempt at a graphic

2 sorry I hate to be harsh, but here are some tips:

1 - the quality looks really bad. Did you save it with save for web or save as? I would recommend save for web and make sure the quality is set to very high or maximum

2 - the red color is too strong... try reducing that a bit

3 - and I would add a border (but it isn't that much of a problem if you don't )

I hope I didn't discourage you... good luck with your future stuff

[Petkorazzi]

Great thread. Hope noone takes my comments personally.

Originally Posted by Sammy 4 eva!!!

Can you guys please rate these

1)

2)

3)

4)

5)

6)

Tips for how I can improve would be great

1) 9 If you saved it as JPG or PNG, the pic would be of better quality. The coloring = perfect.

2) 8 Maybe increasing the saturation and maybe brightness would help?

3) 7 Ana's skin looks a bit too 'red'.

4) 9 I'd prefer a bit more brightness, though I know some prefer the more natural looks.

5) Same as above.

6) Same as above

Originally Posted by droolv3

It's a game banner, but I really like it

Anyone's ratings or thought :

Originally Posted by 5ean

No that's great thanks. Exactly what the thread it for

How about these?

1)

2)

Birth of a hero 1st banner is great.

The text doesn't really suit the 2nd, though.

[Nicole.]

Can you guys please rate this.

[Droolv]

7.5 - Love the background used, it's really suits the banner. The font should be abit bitter, and Donald is abit too dark for my liking. His hand is also fuzzy The doble border is fantastic.

[Sean.]

8.5. Everything is great exept for the font - I can't read it

[Poiree]

Originally Posted by Kyber

Can you guys please rate this.

6

the background is great as well as the font, but:

1 - you wrote Donlad

2 - the picture isn't extracted from the background well enough. The edges look fuzzy, they should be a bit softer

[Andreas]

DonLAD
Sorry