[James]

Originally Posted by AdeyC

He can because he discussed the likelihood with me of the then WTF Board's likely acceptance/agreement of him doing similar for WTF and I explained the situation as I saw it, along with the reasons.

That again wasn't the point that was made. It was suggested that you post what other people (not just you, not just the board) think. It was unrelated to a situation with the WTA board. I am sure you could very well predict their response based on previous experiences. I disagreed with the generic statement Sfar made.

[AdeyC]

Originally Posted by James

That again wasn't the point that was made. It was suggested that you post what other people (not just you, not just the board) think. It was unrelated to a situation with the WTA board. I am sure you could very well predict their response based on previous experiences. I disagreed with the generic statement Sfar made.

You're losing me now - I'm lost on what point we are discussing or what you are trying to say.

[James]

Originally Posted by AdeyC

You're losing me now - I'm lost on what point we are discussing or what you are trying to say.

I noticed that we were talking at cross purposes. Let me try to explain one more time:

Sfar tried to explain that you are sometimes less diplomatic, but often say what other people think, but do not post (generic statement). I said in response that it would be hard to know what every TT player thinks, so I did not think it was necessarily true that you post what other people think. Nothing more, nothing less. Sfar then clarified his statement and that made me understand it better.

I didn't understand your response that you knew him well (not related to the statement) or that you could explain well how the board here would react (again not related to the statement).

[AdeyC]

Originally Posted by James

I noticed that we were talking at cross purposes. Let me try to explain one more time:

Sfar tried to explain that you are sometimes less diplomatic, but often say what other people think, but do not post (generic statement). I said in response that it would be hard to know what every TT player thinks, so I did not think it was necessarily true that you post what other people think. Nothing more, nothing less. Sfar then clarified his statement and that made me understand it better.

I didn't understand your response that you knew him well (not related to the statement) or that you could explain well how the board here would react (again not related to the statement).

OK (I think - I'm still a bit confused) - so we're all sorted then?

[sfar]

Originally Posted by AdeyC

OK (I think - I'm still a bit confused) - so we're all sorted then?

Yes, I think we are...

[James]

Originally Posted by AdeyC

OK (I think - I'm still a bit confused) - so we're all sorted then?

Why would we not be?

[AdeyC]

Originally Posted by Frederik

Picks that are only sent to the person that posted the OOP don't count on TF (if that person is not the manager).

If that's what happened on MTF.

It was - theres the OOP and the picks were sent to the wrong manager despite it being written an inch high

http://www.menstennisforums.com/show...&postcount=126

picks weren't accepted - don't see how that makes anyone 'Nazi' for not accepting them - it would be the same here.

[Andreas]

Originally Posted by AdeyC

It was - theres the OOP and the picks were sent to the wrong manager despite it being written an inch high

http://www.menstennisforums.com/show...&postcount=126

picks weren't accepted - don't see how that makes anyone 'Nazi' for not accepting them - it would be the same here.

No, it wouldn't be the same here, and there have been many, many cases where people accidentially sent to the one posting the OOP. I've never seen those picks not accepted.

How many times do I have to say that I was in a hurry and didn't scroll further down?

Anyway, this is a really pointless discussion. You have your opinion and I have mine

[Frederik]

Originally Posted by Andreas

No, it wouldn't be the same here, and there have been many, many cases where people accidentially sent to the one posting the OOP. I've never seen those picks not accepted.

It would be the same here. Here's one of a handful of posts in the "ask the board" thread where a board member confirmed this.

Originally Posted by Chris 84

if somebody makes a post with the oop and clearly includes who the picks are meant to be sent to, and the player then sends to someone else, then the picks should not cannot be accepted.

[AdeyC]

Originally Posted by Andreas

No, it wouldn't be the same here, and there have been many, many cases where people accidentially sent to the one posting the OOP. I've never seen those picks not accepted.

How many times do I have to say that I was in a hurry and didn't scroll further down?

Anyway, this is a really pointless discussion. You have your opinion and I have mine

Everyone can see for themselves now what the situation and circumstances were. I am correcting you that it is wrong and bandying the word 'nazi' about is inappropriate. Read Posts 55 and 69 for yourself, two WTF Board Members state what the rules are here.