Re: Who is the most talanted female singer of Beyonce's generation?
Streisand
__________________ Supporting New Zealand Tennis and its future endeavours ~Stosur~Venus~Clijsters~Petkovic~Wozniacki~Schiavo ne~King~Radwanska~Serena~Li~Zheng~Date-Krumm~Voegele~Erakovic~Doi Love the player and the game
Come View the Family Business: Moutere Grove, certified Organic Olive Oils http://www.mouteregrove.co.nz/ Kia Kaha
Re: Who is the most talanted female singer of Beyonce's generation?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Invisible Fan
Aren't singers musicians?
Quote:
Originally Posted by papa_action
why/.==]]]/.?
i for one do think that writing songs and playing an instrument is crucial to being "a musician". people like brandy, christina aguilera or britney spears are performers, they interpret songs written by other people. it's an art form, but it's not being a musician. i don't mean this in a judgmental way. but would you really talk about "that musician kelly rowland"?
Re: Who is the most talanted female singer of Beyonce's generation?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Beat
i for one do think that writing songs and playing an instrument is crucial to being "a musician". people like brandy, christina aguilera or britney spears are performers, they interpret songs written by other people. it's an art form, but it's not being a musician. i don't mean this in a judgmental way. but would you really talk about "that musician kelly rowland"?
Christina has co-wrote pretty much all her songs since her debut . "Beautiful" being the most notable exception.
Re: Who is the most talanted female singer of Beyonce's generation?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Beat
i for one do think that writing songs and playing an instrument is crucial to being "a musician". people like brandy, christina aguilera or britney spears are performers, they interpret songs written by other people. it's an art form, but it's not being a musician. i don't mean this in a judgmental way. but would you really talk about "that musician kelly rowland"?
Well I disagree. Vocals are an instrument if you consider the fact that most of the songs these artists do would be nothing without their vocals (with the exception of Britney's Femme Fatale album - the instrumentals are AMAZING!!!!!)
and just to add to the discussion, if someone hypothetically hits a cowbell or a cymbal in a song does that make them more of a musician than Christina or Brandy who put a lot of effort into their vocals, harmonies etc just because they're playing an "instrument"?
Re: Who is the most talanted female singer of Beyonce's generation?
Britney's a real interesting case. She had all the tools when she was younger to become a really good singer.
Her voice is still cute, but didn't quite develop as it could've. And of course she used to dance her ass off before her knee got wrecked. She's far from talentless.
Re: Who is the most talanted female singer of Beyonce's generation?
Quote:
Originally Posted by FlameOn
Her voice is still cute, but didn't quite develop as it could've. And of course she used to dance her ass off before her knee got wrecked. She's far from talentless.
Re: Who is the most talanted female singer of Beyonce's generation?
christina would never be able to sing songs like 'listen' 'i care' 'love on top' 'speechless' someone who is choking in simple middle notes wouldn't be able to even dream of even touching the upper belts for a slight second, let alone sustaining them and going back and forth
and single ladies is nothing but a tempo song, so that doesn't prove anything
Who is the most talanted female singer of Beyonce's generation?
. "Beautiful" being the most notable exception.
.
