[Jalil Sherman]

Theres a bunch of female pop singers born between 1978 and 1982 that hit it big in the late 90s/early 2000s. Which one of them do ou think is the mmost talented musician?

Pole to come.

[Imperfect Angel]

Beyonce. She basically never gives any bad performances. and won the most Grammys, slightly more than all the other options combined(?)

[Miss Atomic Bomb]

Beysus...by far.

[Pops Maellard]

Christina. All the rest of them might as well move over when she starts singing.

BTW Kelly Rowland but no Kelly Clarkson in the poll?

[Gdsimmons]

Are we talking entertaining or SINGING? Cuz if we are talking about singing purely then Beyonce doesnt cut it.

I think Alicia Keys is a great singer. So is Xtina when she just sings and not all those unnecessary runs. Also Monica

SB: What in the hell is Kelly Rowland doing on there!?!

[Mikey.]

From that list I'd say Christina.

[Pops Maellard]

Originally Posted by Gdsimmons

Are we talking entertaining or SINGING? Cuz if we are talking about singing purely then Beyonce doesnt cut it.

I think Alicia Keys is a great singer. So is Xtina when she just sings and not all those unnecessary runs. Also Monica

SB: What in the hell is Kelly Rowland doing on there!?!

Everytime I hear Alicia live I never think she's that good .

[Jalil Sherman]

Originally Posted by Gdsimmons

Are we talking entertaining or SINGING? Cuz if we are talking about singing purely then Beyonce doesnt cut it.

I think Alicia Keys is a great singer. So is Xtina when she just sings and not all those unnecessary runs. Also Monica

SB: What in the hell is Kelly Rowland doing on there!?!

I'm thinking the entire package, songs, vocals, songwriting, performing etc...basically how talented they are as a musician

Kelly has had a more memorable career than Monica IMO. And anyway there's always to OTHER option

ETA: Alicia Keys was a disaster on Whitney's funeral. Her voice sounds so raggedy and harsh all the time...ugh. Talented songwriter/producer though.

I voted for Nelly because quite frankly her versatility, musicianship (she plays a number of instruments) and her Folklore album are greater than anything any of these women have EVER done. It's a shame it was overlooked as it was.

[Pops Maellard]

Originally Posted by papa_action

I'm thinking the entire package, songs, vocals, songwriting, performing etc...basically how talented they are as a musician

Kelly has had a more memorable career than Monica IMO. And anyway there's always to OTHER option

In that case it rules out Beyonce immediately with her song credit thievery .

[Jalil Sherman]

Originally Posted by FlameOn

In that case it rules out Beyonce immediately with her song credit thievery .

that's a talent

[Gdsimmons]

Originally Posted by papa_action

I'm thinking the entire package, songs, vocals, songwriting, performing etc...basically how talented they are as a musician

Kelly has had a more memorable career than Monica IMO. And anyway there's always to OTHER option

ETA: Alicia Keys was a disaster on Whitney's funeral. Her voice sounds so raggedy and harsh all the time...ugh. Talented songwriter/producer though.

I voted for Nelly because quite frankly her versatility, musicianship (she plays a number of instruments) and her Folklore album are greater than anything any of these women have EVER done. It's a shame it was overlooked as it was.

You cant judge AKeys on that alone. She was singing at a funeral....where someone died. Someone close to her. Im sure she was emotional and crying before.

Outside of DC, Kelly Rowland really hasnt done much. She had the song with Nelly like 10 years ago and then Motivation. Thats about it. But she is talented.

Originally Posted by FlameOn

In that case it rules out Beyonce immediately with her song credit thievery .

Ohhhh

[Imperfect Angel]

Originally Posted by Gdsimmons

Are we talking entertaining or SINGING? Cuz if we are talking about singing purely then Beyonce doesnt cut it.

I think Alicia Keys is a great singer. So is Xtina when she just sings and not all those unnecessary runs. Also Monica

SB: What in the hell is Kelly Rowland doing on there!?!

With that she deserves to be there.

Originally Posted by papa_action

I'm thinking the entire package, songs, vocals, songwriting, performing etc...basically how talented they are as a musician

Kelly has had a more memorable career than Monica IMO. And anyway there's always to OTHER option

ETA: Alicia Keys was a disaster on Whitney's funeral. Her voice sounds so raggedy and harsh all the time...ugh. Talented songwriter/producer though.

I voted for Nelly because quite frankly her versatility, musicianship (she plays a number of instruments) and her Folklore album are greater than anything any of these women have EVER done. It's a shame it was overlooked as it was.

She was crying before she performed. Technically she didn't do it well but at least I felt it. But yeah, somehow her vocals are a little overrated. Maybe her voice is also declining?

[Marcelo.]

Beyoncé followed by Alicia Keys, few steps above the others

[Jalil Sherman]

Originally Posted by Gdsimmons

You cant judge AKeys on that alone. She was singing at a funeral....where someone died. Someone close to her. Im sure she was emotional and crying before.

Outside of DC, Kelly Rowland really hasnt done much. She had the song with Nelly like 10 years ago and then Motivation. Thats about it. But she is talented.



Ohhhh

When Love Takes Over was also a huge hit

And yes she hasnt done much but who else was i supposed to add... Mandy Moore?

Originally Posted by Imperfect Angel

She was crying before she performed. Technically she didn't do it well but at least I felt it. But yeah, somehow her vocals are a little overrated. Maybe her voice is also declining?

Her voice is always awful to me TBH

[McPie]