TennisForum.com  

TennisForum.com (http://www.tennisforum.com/index.php)
-   Tennis Slovenia (http://www.tennisforum.com/forumdisplay.php?f=670)
-   -   Tennis Slovenia Forum? (http://www.tennisforum.com/showthread.php?t=392215)

Zamboni Sep 26th, 2009 08:28 PM

Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
There has been a popular request to change this forum into a general Tennis Slovenia forum, like the Daniilidou forum has been changed into a Tennis Greece forum.
We discussed this between mods and admins, and decided it's a good idea, that makes a lot of sense. We're not sure though whether everyone who has voted for this forum realises that there will not be a Srebotnik subforum in the Tennis Slovenia forum. So, before who create the new forum, we want to make sure you still want the forum under that condition.

Thoughts and opinions are welcome in here.

Boreas Sep 27th, 2009 08:46 AM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
So, basically we need to sacrifice Srebotnik's subforum in order to gather Slovene girls in this very same forum. Honestly I don't know where's the trick. Is this because a)Kata has fallen out of top 100, b)she's getting old, c)there's not enough interest in her forum, d) admins don't feel like spending too much time on this topic?

why exactly can't we keep Kata's subforum? It has been here for ages and it's not quite fair to her fans to close it down.

I have nothing against your idea, but I think other people might have different opinions. However, it's up to Kata's fans if they want her forum to fall apart:shrug:

iGOAT Sep 27th, 2009 05:36 PM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
Well the Slovene forum would still be the same as her present one, it would just have threads for all the Slovene girls in it and then you guys could request she gets a forum added for just herself after.

Tanja8 Sep 28th, 2009 08:13 AM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
I agree with Boreas ...
well, it seems that Kata has been "written off" by some people here. However, things don`t seem consistent here ... we still have subforums for Davenport, Pierce, Golovin, Vaidišova ...

But - I don`t have an illusion that we (users) are important here. Admins have the last word - so let it be.
If you ask me - Kata should have her subforum. Less than a year ago she was top 20. And top 5 doubles player for ages. Than injury ... she might not come back but we (her fans) hope she will.
How long has it been since Vaidišova was top ten? 2,3 years? Oh, but she is more interesting than Kata for her long legs, boyfriend etc. :rolleyes:
I thought this forum is about tennis not jet-set and rumours about "celebrities". Maybe I was wrong ...

*Jool* Sep 28th, 2009 11:02 AM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
I'm not fond of the idea to discuss Polona Hercog or Masa Zec 's results in the same thread as Kata's :o
(no offense ...)

*Jool* Sep 28th, 2009 11:04 AM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
^^ I may not get the exact point od this merging though
is it just the name of the forum that changes from "Katarina Srebotnik" to "Tennis Slovenia" ? and then there are threads for each player ?
if so , why not ;)

Boreas Sep 28th, 2009 11:14 AM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
True, but that means no subforum for Kata. I mean, i guess it's not a drastical decision to close down her forum, but since it was there for so long, i find that a bit unfair to her fans

Zamboni Sep 28th, 2009 11:27 AM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by *Jool* (Post 16567894)
^^ I may not get the exact point od this merging though
is it just the name of the forum that changes from "Katarina Srebotnik" to "Tennis Slovenia" ? and then there are threads for each player ?
if so , why not ;)

Yes, that's the point.
We're not closing down her forum, we're changing it into a Tennis Slovenia forum (so, adding threads for other players). If you guys still want that.

*Jool* Sep 28th, 2009 11:34 AM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
and what happens to all the threads already created for Kata ? they remain the same?

personnally I don't really mind having threads for other slovenian players in the forum , I just won't post there , it won't change a lot for me :shrug:

question is : is this really necessary ? I mean, you've had requests from posters willing to have forums/threads for Hercog, Klepac, Zec ... ? if noone posts there ...

Zamboni Sep 28th, 2009 11:41 AM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by *Jool* (Post 16568108)
and what happens to all the threads already created for Kata ? they remain the same?

personnally I don't really mind having threads for other slovenian players in the forum , I just won't post there , it won't change a lot for me :shrug:

question is : is this really necessary ? I mean, you've had requests from posters willing to have forums/threads for Hercog, Klepac, Zec ... ? if noone posts there ...

We had a lot of requests for a Tennis Slovenia forum (look at the Official Player forum request thread in Bug/Error forum). We are willing to create this, but we will not create a Srebotnik forum in that subforum. So, basically, we will change the name of this forum and add threads for other Slovenian players.
We did the same with Daniilidou's forum, which turned into a Tennis Greek forum. After that we got complaints about Eleni not having her own forum anymore, that's why we check first now.

*Jool* Sep 28th, 2009 11:49 AM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
no problem with me as long as we have threads to discuss about Kata I think it's cool that other posters are also able to post things about their faves :hatoff:

can't talk for all the other Kata fans though , obviously :lol:
:wavey:

esdee Sep 28th, 2009 03:28 PM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
I think Kata's results and previous ranking should be given consideration. I have no problem with Tennis Slovenia (although I can't imagine many postings for other players, no offence), but I think Kata should have her own sub-forum.

Bероника Sep 28th, 2009 06:25 PM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
Well I'm Eleni fan and her forum or tennis Greece as it's called now is now a big mess,Eleni's threads are spread everywhere so I wouldn't like this to happen here also for Kata.But again I don't post here as much as I post there,so maybe the people who post more regularly and are more active in this forum should tell better than me.

*Jool* Sep 28th, 2009 06:58 PM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
yes that might be annoying :( still, we get our "Katarina Srebotnik!" thread where we post almost everything abt Kata, and dont post that often in other more specific threads , but I guess it's vastly due to Kata's lack of tennis activity in 2009 :awww:

shouldn't we need a poll? :shrug: (don't know what I would vote for yet tho :lol: )

when do you admins plan to do that if that happens?

hellas719 Sep 30th, 2009 01:26 AM

Re: Tennis Slovenia Forum?
 
I agree with Veronika;)
Before Tennis Greece, I asked for the other Greek players' threads to be moved to ROW, and nothing:(
Then Eleni's forum got deleted, which I don't understand, because although she was doing bad, she still had fans and forum activity:shrug:
I think Srebotnik's forum should stay;)


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:39 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.