|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|Feb 13th, 2005 09:10 PM|
Originally Posted by goldenlox
|Feb 13th, 2005 06:15 PM|
|Derek.||Dinara is definetly playing like she's a top 20 player. Let's see if she keeps it up.|
|Feb 13th, 2005 06:13 PM|
|KV||And she def. A. Mauresmo Improved mentally, a few weeks ago she wouldn't have def. T. Golovin after being 3-5 down in the FS. She took a big step forward, celebrates her first win against a topplayer after losing several times in 3 setters vs. the top ranked. As well like E. Dementieva she returned a large number of first serves from Momo. Of course as for D. Safina it always will be diffiuclt to become as good as her broth.|
|Feb 13th, 2005 06:06 PM|
Originally Posted by ys
|Feb 13th, 2005 06:02 PM|
|goldenlox||If she beats Mauresmo in a Tier II final, she might be top 5 material.|
|Feb 20th, 2004 12:38 AM|
I can understand why people are down on Dinara. She still has a lot to prove.
But for a 17 year old, she is right on target. I look forward to watching Dinara move up the rankings.
|Feb 19th, 2004 03:26 PM|
I said that 2 years ago, ys? And how I am jumping on the bandwagon? I think Myskina is now a top 5 caliber tennis player. She has proved me wrong. I used to think she was only a top 10 caliber player. And I think Maria Sharapova could be a top 5 player in a couple of years. That's hardly jumping on the bandwagon. And when I say Myskina will make the top 5 and Sharapova could make the top 5 I'm thinking they will move in and out of the top 5. I have seen nothing from either of them that says they will be solid memebers of the top 5. Of course if Maria can develope her serve into a weapon and add about 20 pounds of weight to her frame then it's a differsnt story.
I don't see why people are down on Safina. She needs a couple years to develope and get comfortable with her height, frame and hardhitting game.
Good point about Petrova, GL. Poor Nadia. If she could only stay healthy.
|Feb 18th, 2004 11:51 PM|
The word "potential" leaves it too wide open.
How about - who will be in the top 5 for years?
Right now, Nastya is the only player I would bet on. But I keep hope for many others.
But the real goal is to win majors and be #1. Everyone has to improve a lot.
|Feb 18th, 2004 11:31 PM|
Originally Posted by the cat
|Feb 18th, 2004 11:15 PM|
|*JR*||Give Coach Choudury a little time with Sister Safina, OK?|
|Feb 18th, 2004 11:14 PM|
Nadia made the semis of last year's French Open. Now she is injured.
Elena D. at Amelia Island played like she can be top 5.
Sustaining it, and staying healthy, make it so difficult.
Dinara and Maria are tall and early in their careers. So potential is there. Over time, we will find out how good they can be. If they stay healthy.
|Feb 18th, 2004 11:00 PM|
|the cat||Well said. Making the top 5 is hard enough. But staying there is even harder.|
|Feb 18th, 2004 10:16 PM|
They mean top 5 like Kim. Where the player is in the top 5 for years.
Potential and doing it is different. You have to go deep into a lot of tournaments and stay healthy.
When most players are rolling and win a lot they get injured.
Nastya has not had a bad loss (to a non-top 5) since Linz when she lost to Schnyder.
If Nastya keeps that up, she will be a top 5 player for a long time.
|Feb 18th, 2004 09:56 PM|
Other than Myskina, I see only 1 other Russina with top 5 potential. And her name is Maria Sharapova. But a few of them do appear to be top 10 material. I can see as many as 8 Russina's in the WTA top 20 in the near future with 3 Russina's in the top 10 at the same time. We really can't ask for much more than that the the Williams sisters and the top 2 Belgians on the WTA scene.
ys, Myskina is top 5 material because she's almost in the top 5. I know she took advantage of the absence of the Williams sisters. But so did everyone else. Especially Justine Henin.
|Feb 16th, 2004 10:44 PM|
Now that I think about it, Nastya, Elena D., Lena, Nadia, Dinara, Maria S., and Vera Z. all have top 5 potential.
And I'm still optimistic about Sveta, but I'll not count her at this time.
They need to stay healthy and focused.To actually do it is much different than being able to play at that level once in a while.
|This thread has more than 15 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|