TennisForum.com - Reply to Topic
Thread: Barthel's serve - discuss Reply to Thread
Title:
Message:
Trackback:
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:
 

Register Now



In order to be able to post messages on the TennisForum.com forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.

User Name:
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.

Password:


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:
OR

Log-in









Image Verification
Please enter the six letters or digits that appear in the image opposite.

Registration Image

  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

  Topic Review (Newest First)
Apr 28th, 2015 04:34 PM
pov
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

Quote:
Originally Posted by Grininel View Post
Maybe it's time for 'major tweaking' before it's too late? pov pointed out pretty well about her hitchy(?) and unique action.
I was surprised to see this bumped. But yeah "hitchy" is a good description. There's a moment where she ummm .. hitches . .if slowed down it would like a minor glitch in an animation program. When I first noticed it was new (to me anyway) now it's become a habit. She likely isn't even aware of it. Hopefully her coach is though at this point I'd think the most efficient fix would be to find a way to use that hitch in a favorable way.
Apr 21st, 2015 05:50 PM
Tecumseh
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

With her given serve technique Mona can already serve very big, and with a little technical adjustment she would be one of the biggest servers of the game, that’s for sure.

BUT

you don’t need to improve your weapons if you don’t have the guts to use them on the battlefield. As simple as that!

Mona is not a warrior and THIS is her fundamental problem; she is not someone who uses her weapons to create maximum damage to her opponents. And as long as she doesn’t find her inner warrior we don’t need to discuss technical changes.

Just imagine what Sharapova would do if she had such a potential on her first serve.


Quote:
Originally Posted by HowardH View Post
I've never seen a tall player who was successful without using the serve as a weapon. Because when you are tall your agility is affected somewhat (Mona is quite a smooth mover considering her height) but you theoretically could develop a great serve.
I think her weak defensive forehand is the main reason why she should serve big. Her movement/foot speed (in contrast to her sloppy footwork) would be good enough to compensate for an average serve, in my opinion. In fact, I regard her as the quickest tall player since Venus Williams at her peak.
Apr 21st, 2015 11:59 AM
HowardH
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

She clearly needs to improve her ability to hold serve now.

Whether this involves technical "tweaking" of the serve or just a ton of work on it or a more aggressive attitude when hitting it, she needs to change something. For some players (usually shorter players who rely more on great rallying) holding serve can be just about placing a medium speed serve well and quickly taking control of the rallies (Ferrer, for instance, does this). Others rely on more direct damage from the serve, and become good at killing the easy returns from their serves or getting free points (Federer, Raonic). I think for Mona she probably needs to get a reasonable amount of damage from the serve itself, not just start the point, if she wants to go higher. I mean, she's so tall. I've never seen a tall player who was successful without using the serve as a weapon. Because when you are tall your agility is affected somewhat (Mona is quite a smooth mover considering her height) but you theoretically could develop a great serve. It would be like a short player trying to be successful without being able to run fast or have fitness.

It could even be as simple as a loss of confidence that has affected her whole game. I mean, she doesn't need to be Sampras, Federer or Raonic with the serve, she just needs to be able to not be broken 70% of the time and she will win more.

Anyway, this is all speculative for the moment because I couldn't see what was happening or why she was losing serve all the time. But when she had to serve to stay in the match, I was pretty sure she wouldn't hold, unfortunately.
Apr 20th, 2015 10:32 PM
Grininel
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

Quote:
Originally Posted by pov View Post
Could be. Maybe in the moments I saw those close-ups her serve didn't feel flowing to her and like most players she sought to compensate.

IMO Barthel's serve doesn't need any reworking or major tweaking. I do think that she can benefit by staying more relaxed through it.
Maybe it's time for 'major tweaking' before it's too late? pov pointed out pretty well about her hitchy(?) and unique action.
I have to swallow my words that she would find a way without a big serve.
Mar 18th, 2013 02:01 PM
Kerber Counter
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

Quote:
Originally Posted by pov View Post
I've been posting in Barthel threads before you jumped on the bandwagon.
No, he isn't a bandwagoner at all. I know him very well.

Mar 18th, 2013 01:46 AM
joy division
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

Thanks for the little tennis lesson, Howard and for working out the details of her weakness on serve.
I doubt that she will manage to produce such a proper kick serve as Federer and Stosur can do.
But she`s working on it and her serve is still very efficient and one of her main weapons.
Compared to the last season imo she was putting more pace but also more risk on the first serve. Looking at the pretty high first service percentages in this season it has become safer.
I could see that in a line with a plan to level up her game and make it more reliable and solide overall.
Mar 17th, 2013 07:57 PM
HowardH
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

Quote:
Originally Posted by joy division View Post
I think I have a clue what you mean. But is it accidentally ? How can that happen, and is it an advantage or an disadvantage in your opinion ?
It's accidental, or rather, she cannot fully control when it happens. This is a very common problem for people with the kick serve, it often comes out with slice instead of straight kick or twist especially on the deuce side. It's quite tricky to hit up the back of the ball on the serve without coming around the right hand side of the ball, and whenever you come around that right hand side it slices or becomes slice-topspin. Her toss for the second serve tends to be a bit too far to the right for a kick serve, but on the ad side she can sometimes get away with it and still hit a good kick serve out wide. She also tends to stand a bit too upright and she doesn't really arch her back to the left enough on the kick serve (although in reality a lot of that arch is actually created by angling the entire back to the left, not so much by actually bending at the vertebrae, look at Federer's back position on the second serve, Stosur as well).

It's a slight disadvantage because it makes the placement of her second serve a bit questionable at times, often centrally placed or in the forehand side. It becomes possible for an aggressive returner to run around her second serve or predict it more easily. She cannot fully rely on her kick serve to find the backhand corner under pressure on the deuce side in particular, but this is less of an issue in the women's game where the forehands are not so big normally. It also makes her a bit more likely to doublefault, because on the second serve some of the spin will become slice instead and reduce the amount of topspin she gets.

A lot of female players can't hit a true kick serve anyway. So at this stage it isn't that big a deal, so long as it doesn't lead to too many double faults. It also shouldn't be much of an issue against left handers, because you need that slice/topspin mixture on your second serve against lefties, to get your second serve to their backhand. Also her natural slice is pretty useful on the first serve out wide.

When she gets it right her kick serve on the ad side is quite nice, but I can't remember her hitting a real kick serve on the deuce side. I think she should be able to do it though.

For an example of this tendency causing her problems, see this service game here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fiNf3l2lJXA&t=40m0s
Mar 17th, 2013 09:11 AM
joy division
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

Quote:
Originally Posted by HowardH View Post
Her serve is strong. She favours slice serves in general, and sometimes she accidentally gets a bit of slice which she doesn't intend to have. It can appear on her second serve when she tries to go the backhand but slices it towards the centre of the box, but it also appears on her first serve when she tries to go up the T on the deuce side. Overall her serve is quite nice though.
I think I have a clue what you mean. But is it accidentally ? How can that happen, and is it an advantage or an disadvantage in your opinion ?
Mar 17th, 2013 04:04 AM
yoite
Quote:
Originally Posted by pov View Post
IMO Barthel's serve doesn't need any reworking or major tweaking. I do think that she can benefit by staying more relaxed through it.
I couldn't agree more.:thumbup:

Sent from Verticalsports.com Free App
Mar 16th, 2013 07:33 PM
pov
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

Quote:
Originally Posted by yoite View Post
Constancy is the main problem of her serve I think.
Could be. Maybe in the moments I saw those close-ups her serve didn't feel flowing to her and like most players she sought to compensate.

IMO Barthel's serve doesn't need any reworking or major tweaking. I do think that she can benefit by staying more relaxed through it.
Mar 16th, 2013 07:27 PM
The Dawntreader
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tecumseh View Post
I think Mona could improve her serve by deploying her body a little more in her service motion. Right now her serve is mainly about her armswing in my opinion.
Indeed.

Barthel's strength and weakness on serve is how free and loose her racquet arm is.
Mar 16th, 2013 07:25 PM
pov
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

Quote:
Originally Posted by Raiden View Post
Come on guys, Mona has one of the very best serves out there. She was in the top ten of ace leaders in 2012, above Kvitova (who is universally regarded as one of the best servers).

So I don't buy the notion of Mona's serve being inadequate or mediocre (I know you didn't literally say that but that's what yer effectively implying with all that "she's muscling it" talk)
I don't know where all this is coming from. In fact - it's strange. IMO - like I said - Barthel has a good serve. Does that mean it can't be better? Do you not like to discuss ways in which your faves can improve? Not that any of this discussion is affecting them but, for me, part of being a tennis fan is discussing those things. To those who think that being a fan of a player equals thinking that player is near-perfect in all their aspects . . get over it. Even Federer has some wonky things.
Mar 16th, 2013 11:34 AM
Kerber Counter
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

Her serve is great. Even better than last year.
Mar 16th, 2013 11:23 AM
yoite
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

I think her serve can always be very well. If she can find out the feeling of serve, she can play a lot of aces in the match. But unfortunately, if she lose the felling, there also be a lot of double fault in the match.
Constancy is the main problem of her serve I think.
Mar 16th, 2013 08:37 AM
Hartson
Re: Barthel's serve - discuss

This year her serve is more consistent than in 2012. She's increased a percentage of the first serve (the speed became a little bit less though) and her second serve is improved.
Mona's first serve is one of the best on tour
This thread has more than 15 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may not post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome