PDA

View Full Version : Album War - Blackout v The Fame - Britney v GaGa


Dodoboy.
Jul 9th, 2011, 10:13 PM
Picked two albums I'm sure TF have heard.

Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Again Again
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy

Example to follow
http://ximages.net/images/12172926760323632503.gif

Dodoboy.
Jul 9th, 2011, 10:15 PM
Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Again Again
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy

Gaga - 6
Britney - 6

DRAW :speakles:

Adal
Jul 9th, 2011, 10:15 PM
Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Again Again
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy

:shrug:

young_gunner913
Jul 9th, 2011, 10:21 PM
Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Again Again
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy

LeRoy.
Jul 9th, 2011, 10:22 PM
Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Again Again
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy

Dodoboy.
Jul 9th, 2011, 10:23 PM
LeRoy,
I can't..
http://ximages.net/images/84424197229997604217.gif

Certinfy
Jul 9th, 2011, 10:34 PM
Is it 'wrong' I've hardly heard any of those songs? :o

LeRoy.
Jul 9th, 2011, 10:37 PM
Yes. Please let me revoke you gay card. oh wait.

In The Zone
Jul 9th, 2011, 11:03 PM
Blackout is perfect. Fame has some filler, Blackout doesn't.

~Cherry*Blossom~
Jul 9th, 2011, 11:04 PM
Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Again Again
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy


Gimme More is Britney's best song imo.

Outta This World was my second fave Britney song from this era and it didn't even make the album :sobbing:

Rui.
Jul 9th, 2011, 11:16 PM
Is it 'wrong' I've hardly heard any of those songs? :o

Don't worry... you'll get better at it.. your friend will teach you back at the hotel..

Just kidding :lol:

I actually don't know many of these songs anyway.

Patrick S
Jul 9th, 2011, 11:54 PM
I think ive heard maybe two of these songs. If it could only have been a Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds vs Tom Waits, or The Stooges vs MC5 poll...

delicatecutter
Jul 9th, 2011, 11:56 PM
That's certainly not the tracklist of The Fame I have, but I will play along anyway. I've never heard Again Again so I will replace it with Paper Gangsta, which is one of the best songs on TF and I can't believe it's not on your version.

Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Paper Gangsta
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy

5-7 (And more like 5-6 because I don't like Freakshow or The Fame.)

If I do it by my track-listing:

Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Poker Face
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Solder v Money Honey
Hot as Ice v Starstruck
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Paper Gangsta
Why Should I Be Sad v Brown Eyes

3-9 (3-8)

Novichok
Jul 10th, 2011, 01:32 AM
Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Again Again
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy

Whitehead's Boy
Jul 10th, 2011, 02:05 AM
Perfect Lover and Why Should I Be Sad are clearly fillers.

There is a big gap between The Fame singles and the rest, but it says more about how great those singles are.

In short, I would say Blackout is better as a whole, but Gaga singles are way stronger so I pick the The Fame.

Pump-it-UP
Jul 10th, 2011, 02:24 AM
Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face ---- I CAN'T CHOOSE. :sobbing:
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Again Again
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy

I prefer Blackout tbh but I think most of these song matchups just go in Gaga's favor.

delicatecutter
Jul 10th, 2011, 02:39 AM
Without a doubt, Blackout is more cohesive and a better album, I think. It just shows how silly it is to match up albums track vs. track.

The Witch-king
Jul 10th, 2011, 12:09 PM
Picked two albums I'm sure TF have heard.

Gimme More v Just Dance
Piece of Me v LoveGame
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Again Again
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy


These type of comparisons are completely useless.

Why should I compare Heaven on Earth to Eh, Eh? Or Perfect Lover to Brown Eyes?

If you wanted to know which album people thought was better you should have just asked and preferably put a poll up.

Andy.
Jul 10th, 2011, 12:53 PM
Hardly a fair fight. Britney's best ever Album (by a long shot I might add) v Gaga's first attempt. That being said I will give it a go.

Gimme More v Just Dance (very close)
Piece of Me v LoveGame (very close)
Radar v Paparazzi
Break the Ice v Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
Heaven on Earth v Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)
Get Naked (I Got a Plan) v Poker Face
Freakshow v The Fame
Toy Soldier v Money Honey
Hot As Ice v Again Again
Ooh Ooh Baby v Boys Boys Boys
Perfect Lover v Brown Eyes
Why Should I Be Sad v Summerboy

(5-7) I guess Gaga wins anyway for me

Viktymise
Jul 10th, 2011, 03:21 PM
The Fame is a tacky piece of shit.

Dodoboy.
Jul 10th, 2011, 05:54 PM
It really is just song v song guys, not trying to find out neccesarily which is the best album.

But to be honest, this is going by tracklisting. Artists have the same purpose for the first song of the album, and a different purpose for the last song of the album. This is consistent for almost every artist. So comparing songs by tracklist is probably most sensible.

This is a bit more fun.