PDA

View Full Version : Femme Fatale vs. Born This Way


Tennisation
May 21st, 2011, 06:32 AM
You know I HAD to go there :devil:. Since Gaga has a total of 17 tracks vs Britney's 16 tracks, I was gonna throw in Radar as a bonus track cuz I KNOW Britney was itching to get that on Femme Fatale but then Leroy reminded me that Brit has a bonus track on the Japan's edition called Scary so ima use that and besides I had to satisfy The Edge Of Glory lovers. :angel: How does everyone else's list compare?

Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

Femme Fatale: 13
Born This Way: 4

LeRoy.
May 21st, 2011, 06:41 AM
You know about "Scary" the bonus track for Japan ?

BpI_uftnO8Q

Tennisation
May 21st, 2011, 06:42 AM
You know about "Scary" the bonus track for Japan ?

BpI_uftnO8QShit you right Leroy, how can I forget that awesome bonus track!

Miss Atomic Bomb
May 21st, 2011, 10:00 AM
For me -

FF (3) vs Born This Way (13)

1) Till The World Ends < Marry The Night
2) Hold It Against Me >. Born This Way
3) Inside Out < Government Hooker
4) I Wanna Go < Judas
5) How I Roll > Americano (How I Roll is my favourite track from FF)
6) Drop Dead Beautiful < Hair
7) Seal It With A Kiss < Scheiße
8) Big Fat Bass < Bloody Mary
9) Trouble For Me < Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
10) Trip To Your Heart > Bad Kids
11) Gasoline = Fashion Of His Love (I like both the tracks)
12) Criminal < Highway Unicorn
13) Up N’ Down < Heavy Metal Lover
14) He About To Lose Me < Electric Chapel
15) Selfish < The Queen
16) Don’t Keep Me Waiting < Yoü And I
17) Scary < The Edge Of Glory

http://xmages.net/storage/10/1/0/4/4/upload/9df1178d.gif

I like and listen to both the artists (http://www.last.fm/user/Artsybury) but BTW in a league much higher than FF, for me.

Vartan
May 21st, 2011, 10:19 AM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

6-2, didn't hear other songs.

WonderfulLee
May 21st, 2011, 10:33 AM
Britney 17-0 :help:

M.S.F
May 21st, 2011, 11:27 AM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn (Road To Love)
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

Born This Way = 12
Femme Fatale = 5

Just Do It
May 21st, 2011, 11:39 AM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

FF 10 - BTW 7

Melange
May 21st, 2011, 12:32 PM
16-1 Britney shitneys all over Kaka's album

Kworb
May 21st, 2011, 12:44 PM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

4 vs 13

Mashabator
May 21st, 2011, 01:15 PM
Gaga's is way better

Adal
May 21st, 2011, 01:27 PM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

12 FF / 5 BTW

Femme Fatale > Born This Way

Pump-it-UP
May 21st, 2011, 06:04 PM
Till The World Ends = Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me < Born This Way
Inside Out > Government Hooker
I Wanna Go = Judas
How I Roll < Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful < Hair
Seal It With A Kiss < Scheiße
Big Fat Bass < Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me < Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart >>> Bad Kids
Gasoline < Fashion Of His Love
Criminal > Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down < Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me <<< Electric Chapel
Selfish <<<<<< The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting <<< Yoü And I
Scary < The Edge Of Glory

FF 3 - BTW 12

Both are strong albums. Only big difference for me is that FF gets weaker towards the end because of the bonus tracks.

In The Zone
May 21st, 2011, 07:00 PM
Very disappointed in Born This Way.

Sp!ffy
May 22nd, 2011, 04:26 AM
Both are terrible autotuned shits.

delicatecutter
May 22nd, 2011, 04:49 AM
So far I've listened to maybe 8 or 9 songs from BTW. Some of them have potential. But she sounds like Madonna in many of the songs, vocally. OTOH, Britney sounds like as if a computer could sing as usual. :inlove:

Pop music has really gone down the shitter these days. Thank God for artists like Adele.

Andy.
May 22nd, 2011, 05:13 AM
Born This Way is so so much better. FF has about 4 or 5 decent songs the rest are pretty bad. I don't know how people can even compare it to Blackout. FF just seems like a bunch of random songs that Britney was given, told to record and thrown into an album. There is no synergy or story to the album. Born this Way has so many great songs and has a message. It also helps that Gaga writes her own stuff, takes risks and can sing.

I just feel with Britney you don't get a sense of who she is from her music or her performances/video's/what she wears like you do from a Gaga/Perry/Rihanna etc. It's just like she is a cardboard cut out of herself being told what to sing, what to wear, how to dance etc. She could get away with the Lip Syncing, not writing her own songs etc before because there was no competition but now we have Gaga, Rihanna, Beyonce, Pink, Katy Perry, Kesha, Kelly Clarkson all either writing or co-writing their music, singing live and dancing and all with unique and individual looks and styles which they have made their own. Britney is getting left behind and she really needed to 'Bring it' with FF to show us that she is still in the game as one of the top girls but FF was no where near good enough to do that. She needed another Blackout level album to do that.

LeRoy.
May 22nd, 2011, 10:05 PM
I have now heard "Born This Way" several times to make a fair judgement.

Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

Femme Fatale 11 > Born This Way 6

Overall I have to say "Born This Way" (the album) is a grower. Most songs need a few listens before you start liking them. Femme Fatale OTOH, I liked a lot of the songs on first listen (exept SIWAK and TBFB)

ExXotikal
May 22nd, 2011, 10:33 PM
Femme Fatale by default

http://s5.tinypic.com/104m4b5.jpg

ExXotikal
May 22nd, 2011, 10:36 PM
Born This Way is so so much better. FF has about 4 or 5 decent songs the rest are pretty bad. I don't know how people can even compare it to Blackout. FF just seems like a bunch of random songs that Britney was given, told to record and thrown into an album. There is no synergy or story to the album. Born this Way has so many great songs and has a message. It also helps that Gaga writes her own stuff, takes risks and can sing.

I just feel with Britney you don't get a sense of who she is from her music or her performances/video's/what she wears like you do from a Gaga/Perry/Rihanna etc. It's just like she is a cardboard cut out of herself being told what to sing, what to wear, how to dance etc. She could get away with the Lip Syncing, not writing her own songs etc before because there was no competition but now we have Gaga, Rihanna, Beyonce, Pink, Katy Perry, Kesha, Kelly Clarkson all either writing or co-writing their music, singing live and dancing and all with unique and individual looks and styles which they have made their own. Britney is getting left behind and she really needed to 'Bring it' with FF to show us that she is still in the game as one of the top girls but FF was no where near good enough to do that. She needed another Blackout level album to do that.

You need Jesus and the Holy Ghost. Seriously? Are you kidding me?

Rihanna ain't writing shizz. Katy, Kesha are HORRIBLE live performers. Especially the later. Noone of them can dance. They can barely sing.

Andy.
May 23rd, 2011, 01:23 AM
You need Jesus and the Holy Ghost. Seriously? Are you kidding me?

Rihanna ain't writing shizz. Katy, Kesha are HORRIBLE live performers. Especially the later. Noone of them can dance. They can barely sing.
At least they are trying unlike Britney who wont/cant sing live or who's idea of dancing these days is strutting around and posing. I just think if she isn't going to sing live and write her own stuff at least kill it with her dancing but she cant even do that anymore.

Serenaluv
May 23rd, 2011, 02:00 AM
I love both albums, however I must say that I feel Britney's songs were less recycled than GaGa's.

Mary Cherry.
May 24th, 2011, 12:18 AM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night I can't decide :sobbing: so they both score 1
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

Femme Fatale 8-10 Born This Way

My judgement might be slightly affected by the fact I played FF to death when it came out.

aznunit2k5
May 24th, 2011, 02:01 AM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

Femme Fatale >>> Born This Way by a long shot. Gaga is a gimmick with no real talent.

delicatecutter
May 24th, 2011, 02:04 AM
:spit: I don't stan for Gaga or Britney and have had negative things to say about both of them but Gaga wins this one by a mile.

Rafito.
May 24th, 2011, 03:25 AM
Britney has a few amazing songs, but the whole Born this way album is amazing so by far BTW :hearts:

Caralenko
May 24th, 2011, 07:43 AM
Gaga is a gimmick with no real talent.

Then what does that make Britney? :confused:

The Witch-king
May 24th, 2011, 07:54 AM
Femme Fatale is a good album but it feels like it could have been done by literally anyone. Her personality does not come through at all and all the autotune does not help.

Right now I'd probably vote for Born This Way.

The Witch-king
May 24th, 2011, 08:02 AM
So far I've listened to maybe 8 or 9 songs from BTW. Some of them have potential. But she sounds like Madonna in many of the songs, vocally. OTOH, Britney sounds like as if a computer could sing as usual. :inlove:

Pop music has really gone down the shitter these days. Thank God for artists like Adele.

People keep saying that and I totally dont hear that at all. Which Madonna are you talking about?:confused:

C. Drone
May 24th, 2011, 09:26 AM
BTW wins easily.

New_balls_please
May 24th, 2011, 05:15 PM
Femme Fatal is alright. BTW is amazing.
GaGa can sing and perform.
Britney can't even lip-sync these days.

young_gunner913
May 24th, 2011, 11:21 PM
Femme Fatale sucked excepted for a few songs.

Alexj
Aug 6th, 2011, 06:02 AM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

Femme Fatale: 11
Born This Way: 6

I miss Fame Gaga :bigcry:

WhatTheDeuce
Sep 20th, 2011, 12:48 AM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

10 FF - 7 BTW

MH0861
Sep 20th, 2011, 01:15 AM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night (Both amazing)
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

9-8 BTW :eek: But my two favorite songs amongst both albums in total both come from FF (TTWE and Criminal).

Lennval
Sep 20th, 2011, 01:24 AM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

13-4 BTW :)

Ayumilover.
Sep 20th, 2011, 01:31 AM
Britney's singles are better, but the rest of the other tracks are much better with Gaga. If you combined their songs together and take the top two,

I would say it's You and I + Till the World Ends.
The next two best songs are Hold it Against Me and Edge of Glory.
The next two are probably Born This Way and Scheisse.
After that, it would be Hair and Judas.
Followed by that is Heavy Metal Lover and I Wanna Go.
Then i would say Merry the Night and Big Fat Base
Followed this time by Government Hooker and Americano.

Given that, Lady Gaga leads Britney 10-4 amongst IMO, the best 14 songs combined.

Therefore, I would pick Born This Way. BTW, i think it's a fantastic CD.

MH0861
Sep 20th, 2011, 02:36 AM
Britney's singles are better, but the rest of the other tracks are much better with Gaga.

I agree with this. FF's singles blow BTW's singles out of the water IMO. What an amazing set of singles from Britney from this album, I love them all.

WhatTheDeuce
Sep 20th, 2011, 04:51 AM
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
These two can really go either way with me, cause I really like both those BTW tracks. I'm slightly biased obviously. It's pretty equal to me all things said. I agree with the general sentiment that Britney's singles > and Gaga's album tracks >.

Dave.
Sep 20th, 2011, 02:53 PM
Till The World Ends vs. Marry The Night
Hold It Against Me vs. Born This Way
Inside Out vs. Government Hooker
I Wanna Go vs. Judas
How I Roll vs. Americano
Drop Dead Beautiful vs. Hair
Seal It With A Kiss vs. Scheiße (two of my fave tracks on either album, but Gaga scrapes it)
Big Fat Bass vs. Bloody Mary (same as above)
Trouble For Me vs. Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Trip To Your Heart vs. Bad Kids
Gasoline vs. Fashion Of His Love
Criminal vs. Highway Unicorn
Up N’ Down vs. Heavy Metal Lover
He About To Lose Me vs. Electric Chapel
Selfish vs. The Queen
Don’t Keep Me Waiting vs. Yoü And I
Scary vs. The Edge Of Glory

Gaga 11-6