PDA

View Full Version : Any statistics experts here or may be professors: Please help: I'm sick with my quiz


Al
Sep 22nd, 2003, 04:48 PM
In my quiz,
this is the question:
The maufacturer claims that the variance in working hours of workers is less than 0.9
And from a random sample size 5, we find that the variance of the sample is 1.1
Test the hypothesis at .05 level of significance.

I really would like to know how we should set up the hypothesis.
Choice 1
Null Hypothesis: variance = 0.9
Alternative Hypothesis : variance > 0.9
Choice 2
Null Hypothesis: variance = 0.9
Alternative Hypothesis : variance < 0.9

In some Thai texts, they just say that because the manufacturer's claim(less than 0.9) does not consist of equal so it can't be the null hypothesis(I mean they just want it to be "does not exceed" more than "less than" if ัyou want to set it to be the null hypothesis.
But I don't think like that I think the 0.9 is just a very small point in a continuous variable system, and we should give the credit to the manufacturer first and set it to be null hypothesis and then try to find enough evidence to reject it

Which one is the real issue? Just the "does not exceed" or " less than"
In the real world we should be able to say less than and it has all rights to be the null hypothesis...
Am I correct? Please help.

lakeway11
Sep 22nd, 2003, 06:23 PM
QUOTE=lakeway11]in the vast majority of cases the researcher sets up the null hypothesis as the one where no significance difference is found thus rejecting the null is what usually what one wants...since the manufacter claims that the variance is less than 0.9 (research hypothesis) it would be set up in this manner:

Ho: the variance of working hours is not less than 0.9
Ha: the variance of working hours < 0.9[/QUOTE]

Al
Sep 23rd, 2003, 09:13 AM
QUOTE=lakeway11]in the vast majority of cases the researcher sets up the null hypothesis as the one where no significance difference is found thus rejecting the null is what usually what one wants...since the manufacter claims that the variance is less than 0.9 (research hypothesis) it would be set up in this manner:

Ho: the variance of working hours is not less than 0.9
Ha: the variance of working hours < 0.9[/QUOTE]

Thanks :) :worship:
But the question is we as a person outside the manufacturer's company not we as a manufacturer.
The quiz ask we think whether the manufacturer's claim is right.
Please make it clear for me again. :worship: :worship: