Nadine is the best singer and has the nicest set of pins. Nicola is the 2nd best singer. Kimberly has the prettiest face. Sarah is a bitch. Cheryl is an untalented stick who beats up toilet attendents.
Jun 16th, 2009, 03:12 AM
I'm seriously bored so here goes my GA dissertation.
Well Nadine is the only one who can actually sing. Meaning she has actual range and control and is actually a talented singer. I was going to write that she could actually be a solo star, but then I remembered that actual singing talent isn't always relevant in that regard. :lol:
Nicola has a pleasant voice but really no range. I do think she's the second best singer despite the fact that she can go off pitch occasionally live.
I'd put Kimberley third. She really has no range at all but she is almost always on-key live at least.
The last two are a toss up.
I'd put Cheryl fourth just because she has a decent tone. However, her pitch can go all over the place. This is when Pro-Tools really helps her lol. She sounds great (or decent at least) in the studio.
Sarah is last because she tends to shout and it's usually scary. Her voice is better suited for rock songs where she could get away with it. She's not a horrible singer, per se, it's just that she's not a pop singer. The only times I ever find her voice enjoyable is when it's very sweet like at the end of "Whole Lotta History". I do not like that she sings so much on what I've heard of Out of Control. She is easily the most irrelevant member of GA.
Even though I'm not British (god I wish!!) I have watched extensive YT interviews in the past few months so I have plenty of experience to form my conclusions.
Cheryl. She's just a breath of fresh air. I love her Geordie accent. She's no pretty princess. She is so down to earth and lovely. I don't know. There is a regal heir about her but I still imagine I could hang out with her.
Kimberley. She's amazing!!! God I just love her. Her infectious smile, her cheeky interviews. She's just an utter delight. Sometimes I feel like she's under-utilized in GA, but obvs not as she is quite popular amongst fans.
Nadine. I love Nadine, but I am trying my hardest to be unbiased. She's a bit Hollywood lol. As much as I'd love to see her as this sweet little girl from Derry, her actions have proved different. Like how she lied about her age to try to make Irish Popstars. Moved to LA. Dated Jesse Metcalfe. I don't know if I know the real Nadine. But it's maybe a good thing that I don't feel like I know her. It's never good to feel you're on equal playing field as your idols. :worship:
Sarah. She's an absolute joy in interviews. I really do like her quite a bit. If I took her outside of the whole GA thing, I think we'd get on quite well. But I think she's irrelevant in GA and her singing isn't helping her cause, ya know?
Nicola. Like I don't feel like I really know anything about her. She doesn't seem to be the most outgoing girl.
Cheryl. Look at her. Enough said.
Kimberley. Simply stunning. Plus she has this aura of being multi-ethnic. She almost looks like Mariah Carey sometimes.
Nadine. Recently it looks likes she might have gotten work done, which seriously frightens me as she is only 24 today. But she's a beautiful girl as many GA videos show.
Sarah. She's just not aging well, but she is cutish.
Nicola. Genes just weren't on her side.
Yeah, so my final verdict of how I rank the girls isn't scientific or anything. It's more of a gut feeling than anything. Just had to put all my feelings out there. :lol: