If Justine defeats Serena at the QFs...

If they both reach the quarters and Justine wins their 3rd consecutive GS maeeting, do you think we will have to put an asterix next to Serena's AO championship?

OMFG. :shrug:

that is like saying Justine's U.S.OPEN AND AO has an asterix because the sisters were killing everyone until their injuries..a little silly

well so far justine has been playing better than serena..but you never know, maybe serena's game starts to improve during the tournament

If we put an asterik next to Serena's AO '07, we put one on Justine's US Open 03. Venus and Serena were conveniently injured and Justine won. Back when Serena and Venus were dominating.

:haha:

Oh hell nooooooooooooo, even though I LOVE JUJU, I must say if Serena didn't have those 4 injuries she had against juju at wimby this year, she could have defeated henin with just 3 injuries.

I'm sorry, but I gotta be real.

:help: .

what if bartoli defeats safina?

LOL Like anything Serena's ever done can be doubted :lol:

I seem to remember the same arrogant assumptions prior to the Justine's Wimbledon semi against Marion.. Even the press asking Venus about how she will approach her match against Justine.

So a post like this is just a wynd up against Marion Bartoli fans. Intentional or not.

One round at a time.

If Serena beats Heninn does an asterisk go beside her French Open title....

How does anyone know Henin is playing better than Serena??? Based on what i saw, Vera would have beaten makarova as bad as Henin did....There is on way to compare the levels vs inferior competition....

SHUT UP DON'T JINX. I think an asterix should really be put by her AO and USO. Why would you put an asterix by it and she beat juju 0-6 7-5 6-3 at Miami IMO that's a good way to follow up a AO title.

Yeeeah!

If Justine played she'd have beated Serena like Bammer did in Hobart :help:

OMFG. :hearts:

Lets not forget that during the AO it was in fact Sharapova who was nr1. No asterix there!

Lets not forget that during the AO it was in fact Sharapova who was nr1. No asterix there!

Sharapova didn't beat Serena twice in the slams...

and about the Miami match... I'm sure Serena would happily swap that win to her losses in RG and Wimb.

:tape:

:tape:

If we're splitting hairs, wouldn't we also have to put an asterisk next to Henin's win at Wimbledon considering Serena was hitting one handed backhands due to her thumb injury?

I don't think most of you really got the point of this thread. :shrug:

If we put an asterik next to Serena's AO '07, we put one on Justine's US Open 03. Venus and Serena were conveniently injured and Justine won. Back when Serena and Venus were dominating.

and 04 since serena didnt play and venus wasnt the same after the 03 injury. what happens at this year has nothing to do with ao 07. serena shouldnt get any asteriks and neither should justine. if u win a slam u win a slam. if ur a troll u a trol l:o

if serena defeats serena.. in serena!! and serena,,,, wins their serena;; consecutive serena:: maeeting, do you think we will have to put an asterix next to Serena""s Serena?? Serenaship? ,,,,,,,,,,,,,

NO! N-O! Simple as that.

They both have dominated their respective G.S.'s

Justine Henin-Roland Garros (2003, 2005, 2006, 2007)
Serena Williams-Australian Open (2003, 2005, 2007)

It'd be like putting an asterik next to Venus's Wimbledon win if she were to lose tomorrow almost. You simply cannot discredit a player from a Slam they are dominating

No, Serena would have defeated Henin in that form and considering Justine's fragile mind....when she is defeated again though, she will inevitably blame an injury, or fatigue (even though she hasn't played for two months), moral, the balls, the alignments of the stars, anything but give Henin any credit...maybe Serena thinks psychologically she gains an edge over Henin by doing it, but I hope she proves me wrong

Lets not forget that during the AO it was in fact Sharapova who was nr1. No asterix there!

nr. 1 seed
she still number 2 at the time

and really her ranking was just a number she played like shit

people always bring up the fact that serena was injured at wimbledon but neglect the fact that justine being injured in miami took a bagel and two mp against serena

but seriously you can't put an asterix next to any of they're slam wins if you're not there you can't win its as simple as that, being healthy is a part of the game too

Lets not forget that during the AO it was in fact Sharapova who was nr1. No asterix there!
Pf lol ok Ntour answered it first ;)