They have got it all wrong. For a start.....
Will and Gareth's voice styles are restricted. They are very much typical "boy band" styles. They haven't got much range vocally. Zoe was harshly criticised tonight. Okay, fair enough the songs she did required exceptional vocal strength, but as for the others, their songs were relatively easy in comparison.
As for Darius, I can't really form much of an opinion on him, to me he seems the best of a bunch that shouldn't be there.
But tonight the true winner lost out. She had it all, her mannerisms and expressions whilst singing are excellent, she's a natural. She may not win Pop-Idol, but I doubt very much she will fade into the darkness, we'll see her again sometime.
And she has such a vibrant personality too, she shows maturity well beyond her age and has the looks aswell... why oh why oh why didn't she go through?
Love the avatar Kisha!