Ruben has a horrible croaky texture to his voice and he sings off key too much for my liking. Don't care how adorable he looks with that cute grin.
Clay... He has a strong voice but I'm shallow and can't get past the way he looks like a pixie in makeup. Maybe if i didn't have to look at him he'll be okay. Stick him on broadway so he wont be on my TV.
Clay will win. Old ladies will vote for him.