Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects - TennisForum.com
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
post #1 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 11th, 2009, 06:00 PM Thread Starter
Lifetime Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 3,712
                     
Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

http://www.newscientist.com/article/...ility-law.html

08 April 2009

SPERM should be subject to the same product liability laws as car brakes, according to a US judge who has given a teenager with severe learning disabilities the go-ahead to sue the sperm bank that provided her with a biological father.

Brittany Donovan, now 13 years old, was born with fragile X syndrome, a genetic disorder causing mental impairment and carried on the X chromosome. She is now suing the sperm bank, Idant Laboratories of New York, under a product liability law more commonly associated with manufacturing defects, such as faulty car brakes.

Donovan does not have to show that Idant was negligent, only that the sperm it provided was unsafe and caused injury. "It doesn't matter how much care was taken," says Daniel Thistle, the lawyer representing Donovan, based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Genetic tests have revealed that she inherited the disorder from her biological father.

Donovan was conceived in Pennsylvania, where a "blood shield law" protects sellers of human bodily material from product liability suits. In New York state, however, sellers are not protected by any such law. On 31 March, federal judge Thomas O'Neill ruled that Donovan's case should be tried in New York.

Wendy Kramer of the Donor Sibling Registry, which helps people conceived through donor gametes find genetic relatives, suspects other sperm recipients may try to sue. "This could open the floodgates," she says.
Williamsser is offline  
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
post #2 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 11th, 2009, 06:14 PM
 
Join Date: Nov 2001
Posts: 27,278
 
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

Seems fair enough.
Kart is offline  
post #3 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 11th, 2009, 06:17 PM
Worshipping the bangs
 
miffedmax's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Larsson's Player Forum
Posts: 52,000
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

So does this mean you can sue your natural parents? What about an egg donor?

I'm not sure I agree, but my opinion doesn't count in this case.

Max
Pass the duct tape and super glue. Lena's done broke my heart one last time.
Onward my LOB! Lena (ret.) Vika Vee TOB Caro Alexa Sabs Wicky Lesia Vania BMS Ekat Andi H. Jo-La Lena V KP2 Lil Bit Kiki Mini Mak Baby Veronika
"I read on the internet that there is something chipmunky about me :-)"--Andrea H.[/SIZE]
Jo-La Queen of Norrland and Bastad
Elena Viatcheslavovna Dementieva--Eternal Goddess of the Divine Bangs
miffedmax is offline  
post #4 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 11th, 2009, 06:21 PM
 
Join Date: Nov 2001
Posts: 27,278
 
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

I think it means you can sue the institution, not the individual.

They have to have some form of liability IMHO otherwise any randon could open up a sperm bank with a few cups and a freezer. I mean - if you're paying for someone's sperm you have an entitlement to expect them to make some efforts to ensure it's free of genetic disease.

It's not as if fragile X syndrome is easy for guys to hide. I definitely wouldn't support suing the actual sperm donor as many people carry a lot of things they don't know about.
Kart is offline  
post #5 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 11th, 2009, 06:56 PM
Senior Member
 
Ciarán's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Salem, MA
Posts: 29,819
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects



Paszek & Chakvetadze & Vaidisova & Sharapova & Pavlyuchenkova & Vekic.
Ciarán is offline  
post #6 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 11th, 2009, 07:39 PM
Senior Member
 
Scotso's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Baltimore, MD
Posts: 47,046
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kart View Post
They have to have some form of liability IMHO otherwise any randon could open up a sperm bank with a few cups and a freezer. I mean - if you're paying for someone's sperm you have an entitlement to expect them to make some efforts to ensure it's free of genetic disease.
As with all medical procedures, there should be standards. But this is the part that bothers me:

Quote:
Donovan does not have to show that Idant was negligent, only that the sperm it provided was unsafe and caused injury. "It doesn't matter how much care was taken," says Daniel Thistle, the lawyer representing Donovan, based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
This opens the door for any unsatisfied "customer" to sue them for any reason. If the girl suffered a birth defect that was not genetic and in no way caused by the sperm bank, should she still be able to sue them because they provided "unsafe" sperm merely because the kid has medical problems?

If they take reasonable precautions they shouldn't be held responsible for genetic defects and such. It can happen to anyone whether they have a sperm donor father or not.


Le Poussin! Faithfully ignoring the haters since 1995.

Le Poulailler de Poussin! (Simontarded.)

Ron Paul for President 2012!
Scotso is offline  
post #7 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 11th, 2009, 07:47 PM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,643
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scotso View Post
As with all medical procedures, there should be standards. But this is the part that bothers me:



This opens the door for any unsatisfied "customer" to sue them for any reason. If the girl suffered a birth defect that was not genetic and in no way caused by the sperm bank, should she still be able to sue them because they provided "unsafe" sperm merely because the kid has medical problems?

If they take reasonable precautions they shouldn't be held responsible for genetic defects and such. It can happen to anyone whether they have a sperm donor father or not.
Do they have tests for every possible genetic defect? In addition some defects will only come into play if the mother is also a carried of the defective gene, so wouldn't she have to be tested as well?
raffles is offline  
post #8 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 11th, 2009, 08:00 PM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 12,343
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

I guess it makes sense since this is where we are headed with genetics.
Maybe in the future a parent will be able to sue because their child is born ugly when they clearly ordered a beautiful one. It'll be like Gattaca.
starin is offline  
post #9 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 11th, 2009, 08:17 PM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,643
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

Quote:
Originally Posted by manatee View Post
I guess it makes sense since this is where we are headed with genetics.
Maybe in the future a parent will be able to sue because their child is born ugly when they clearly ordered a beautiful one. It'll be like Gattaca.
I plan to genetically engineering myself a super athletic beautiful child so she can win Wimbledon and make lots of money on endorsements. They'll be hell to pay if the sperm back provide me with a short, ugly kid. I'll have to sue them for loss of income.
raffles is offline  
post #10 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 11th, 2009, 10:33 PM
 
Join Date: Nov 2001
Posts: 27,278
 
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scotso View Post
This opens the door for any unsatisfied "customer" to sue them for any reason. If the girl suffered a birth defect that was not genetic and in no way caused by the sperm bank, should she still be able to sue them because they provided "unsafe" sperm merely because the kid has medical problems?

If they take reasonable precautions they shouldn't be held responsible for genetic defects and such. It can happen to anyone whether they have a sperm donor father or not.
Agreed. That statement bothers me as well.

I think it's unlikely that they'll have much success with anything other than genetic defects that were known about though.

It would be interesting to know what kind of safeguards they have in place to prevent this kind of thing occurring - I mean asking volunteering sperm donors to fill in a questionnaire is quite different from having them provide some medical evidence (like a letter from their doctor) that they're not known to be carrying anything.

If you think that we allow people to donate blood on the basis of questionnaire alone but then screen the blood for known disease, I don't think it would be unreasonable to expect the same level of investigation here for a service you're paying for.
Kart is offline  
post #11 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 12th, 2009, 02:23 AM
Senior Member
 
Scotso's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Baltimore, MD
Posts: 47,046
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

They look at their complete medical history, they screen them for every disease possible, and then run all the tests on the person again 6 months later to make sure he doesn't have HIV or something else they missed the first time (during which time the sperm is stored).


Le Poussin! Faithfully ignoring the haters since 1995.

Le Poulailler de Poussin! (Simontarded.)

Ron Paul for President 2012!
Scotso is offline  
post #12 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 12th, 2009, 03:07 AM
Team WTAworld
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Day-Dreaming
Posts: 7,810
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

I think this is dumb.


"You Worry About Your Jump Rope and Yourself!" -Coral on Battle of the Sexes 2




Running for the cliff again...
Rtael is offline  
post #13 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 12th, 2009, 06:39 AM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,197
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

This is ridiculous because first of all it is equating human matter to a 'product'. Human beings are complex, they can't be compared to a normal 'product' that a company produces, even if the company did all the checks or did not excerise care, there could still a multitude of ways in which someone could have genetic defects.


And what of instances where someone is born with genetic defects from natural parents? Whose the 'company 'people sue then? God? The Vatican?
Xanadu11 is offline  
post #14 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 12th, 2009, 08:53 AM
Senior Member
 
rockstar's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 6,156
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

she does realise that it wouldnt be her if better/different sperm was used right?

-Daniela Hantuchova-


JELENA JANKOVIC - CAROLINE WOZNIACKI
rockstar is offline  
post #15 of 17 (permalink) Old Apr 12th, 2009, 09:21 AM
Senior Member
 
Polikarpov's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 3,439
                     
Re: Girl sues sperm bank for genetic defects

Tough luck. I mean it's one of the risks she had to take account before going on with the procedure. I think she should just accept her child the way he is, and take good care of him.

Last edited by Polikarpov; Apr 12th, 2009 at 09:28 AM.
Polikarpov is offline  
Reply

Quick Reply
Message:
Options

Register Now



In order to be able to post messages on the TennisForum.com forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.

User Name:
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.

Password:


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:
OR

Log-in









Image Verification
Please enter the six letters or digits that appear in the image opposite.

Registration Image

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page



Posting Rules  
You may not post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome