Marines kills wounded, unarmed resistance fighter - TennisForum.com
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
post #1 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 17th, 2004, 01:39 AM Thread Starter
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Posts: 25,078
                     
Marines kills wounded, unarmed resistance fighter

There are two articles here. One from Al-Jazeera, One from MSNBC. The MSNBC article also has the video footage from the ABCNews cameraman embedded with that marine unit. All three sources are in basic agreement about the events.

One thing that they all DON'T bring up is that the soldier in question was shot, in the face, the day before. I understand the marines are over-extended in Iraq, but I have to ask. Should he have even been on that patrol?

http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exer...6E1B9C3C22.htm
Marines probed as Falluja fighting continues

Tuesday 16 November 2004, 23:59 Makka Time, 20:59 GMT







The prisoner was shot dead in a Falluja mosque

The US military has launched an investigation after video footage showed a marine shooting a wounded and unarmed man in a mosque in the conflict-stricken city of Falluja.



The man was one of five wounded and left in the mosque after US marines fought their way through the area.

A second group of marines entered the mosque on Saturday after reports that fighters opposed to the US presence in Iraq had moved back into it.

Footage from the NBC television crew showed the five still in the mosque. Several appeared to be already close to death, NBC correspondent Kevin Sites said.

He said a marine noticed one prisoner was still breathing. "The marine then raises his rifle and fires into the man's head. The pictures are too graphic for us to broadcast," Sites said.

Rights group Amnesty International said on Monday that both sides in the Falluja fighting had broken the rules governing the rules of war protecting civilians and wounded combatants.

Top UN human rights official Louise Arbour called on Tuesday for an investigation of alleged abuses in Falluja such as disproportionate use of force and the targeting of civilians.

'Top level of accountability'

In an interview with Aljazeera, US marine spokesperson 1st Lieutenant Lyle Gilbert responded to the killing of the wounded man in the Falluja mosque.

"I was not there and have no more information. The pictures were shown on TV but they did not reveal the circumstance that preceded the incidence. We will know after the investigation finishes.

"We the US forces abide by the combat laws and consider ourselves at the top level of accountability."

In response to reports by Falluja residents that US forces had executed injured Iraqis and dragged them behind US tanks Gilbert said: "I will not talk about this issue. The US together with Iraqi forces confronted the terrorists in Falluja. The forces are there to clean the city from rebels and terrorists, regain stability and security in Iraq, and to hold elections so the Iraqi children can play in playgrounds," he said.

'He did nothing wrong'

Marines interviewed in Falluja on Tuesday said they didn't see the shooting as a scandal, rather the act of a comrade who faced intense pressure during the assault on the city.



The Falluja offensive sparked more unrest in Iraq

"I would have shot the insurgent too. Two shots to the head," said Sergeant Nicholas Graham, 24, of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. "You can't trust these people. He should not be investigated. He did nothing wrong."

Meanwhile violence around Falluja continued as four US military boats were attacked and a number of soldiers aboard were wounded after an operation by armed men in the Nassaf district, west of Falluja city, Aljazeera has learned.

Earlier on Tuesday a marine was killed in a car-bomb attack in the south of the city, a marine officer said.

At least 39 US soldiers have been killed since the start of the Falluja offensive eight days ago and more than 250 injured according to the US military.

Crisis played down

Iraq's government has dismissed reports that civilians in Falluja are desperately short of supplies and lacked adequate medical care. Most civilians were reported to have fled the city of 300,000 ahead of the start of the offensive a week ago.

"The Iraqi government strongly rejects suggestions from some sources that there are shortages of supplies in Falluja," a statement from interim Prime Minister Iyad Allawi's office said.



A marine was killed by a car bombed in the month of Falluja

An Iraqi Health Ministry team had visited the city and Falluja hospital and found no shortages, the statement said, adding: "They have confirmed that they found no citizens in need of food or water. It is now clear there are very few citizens in Falluja. Most have already fled from the terrorists."

But the acting manager of Falluja hospital, Salah Issawi, told Aljazeera that the humanitarian situation in the city was still "a disaster".


"We expect there is a disaster in the city. A woman called us pleading us; she said that she is alone with no water, electricity or food and she was scared.

"I plead with the Iraqi ministry of health to pressure the government and US troops to allow relief teams and medical staff to enter the city," he said.

Surge of unrest

The Falluja offensive has sparked a surge in unrest in other areas. In Baquba, north-east of Baghdad, five policemen and 26 fighters were killed in fighting on Monday.

Renewed clashes erupted in the town on Tuesday, residents said.

US troops were also engaging fighters on Tuesday in the northern oil refining town of Baiji, witnesses said. They said fighters had taken to the streets and were waging gun battles with American and Iraqi forces.

***********************************

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6502452/

getCSS("3088867");FREE VIDEO


Marine shooting probe under way
Nov. 16: An investigation is under way into the shooting by a Marine of a wounded and apparently unarmed man on camera in a Fallujah mosque. NBC's Jim Miklaszewski reports.
Nightly News


Taped killing could be PR nightmare for U.S., Iraqi allies
Investigation to explore whether Marine acted in self-defense

The Associated Press
Updated: 9:15 p.m. ET Nov. 16, 2004

BAGHDAD, Iraq - The fatal shooting of a wounded and apparently unarmed man in a Fallujah mosque by a U.S. Marine angered Sunni Muslims in Iraq on Tuesday and raised questions about the protection of insurgents once they are out of action.

advertisement
International legal experts said the Marine may have acted in self-defense because of a danger that a wounded combatant might try to blow up a hidden weapon; a key issue was whether the injured man was a prisoner at the time.

The shooting happened Saturday, one day after the Marine, who has not been identified, was wounded in the face and after another man in his unit was killed by the booby-trapped body of an insurgent.

In a statement Tuesday, the 1st Marine Division said it launched its investigation “to determine whether the Marine acted in self-defense, violated military law or failed to comply with the Law of Armed Conflict.”

It was unclear from the statement whether the incident was reported through the chain of command Saturday or only when the pool footage became generally available two days later.

Political fallout
The incident could cause major political problems for the government of Prime Minister Ayad Allawi and his U.S. backers at a time when Iraqi authorities are seeking to contain a backlash among Sunnis to the invasion of the former insurgent stronghold of Fallujah.

American and Iraqi authorities tried to prevent rage from spreading among Sunnis, many of whom watched dramatic footage of the shooting that aired throughout the day on Al-Jazeera television, a Qatar-based satellite station.

CLICK FOR RELATED COVERAGE
Latest on fighting in Fallujah, Mosul

“Look at this old man who was slain by them,” said Ahmed Khalil, 40, as he watched the video in his Baghdad shop. “Was he a fighter? Was anybody who was killed inside this mosque a fighter? Where are their weapons? I don’t know what to say.”

It was unclear to what extent other Iraqis, particularly the majority Shiite Muslims, cared about the shooting.

Maysoun Hirmiz, 36, a Christian merchant in Baghdad, said she was not satisfied by an announcement by the U.S. military that it had removed the Marine from the battlefield and will investigate whether he acted in self-defense.

Abu Ghraib revisited
“They will say or do the same thing they did with the soldiers who committed the abuses against Iraqi detainees in Abu Ghraib prison, and they are still free, enjoying their lives while they destroyed other peoples’ lives,” Hirmiz said.

The central figures who allegedly carried out the physical abuse and sexual humiliation of inmates at the notorious prison west of Baghdad are currently on trial, facing trial or have already been sentenced.

The Abu Ghraib scandal, which erupted last spring when photos of the abuse became public, generated a worldwide wave of revulsion that raised questions about the treatment of Muslim prisoners in Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere as part of the Bush administration’s war on terror.

The shooting in the Fallujah mosque became public Monday with the airing of the footage taken Saturday by pool correspondent Kevin Sites of NBC News. In his report, Sites said the man who was killed didn’t appear to be armed or threatening in any way, with no weapons visible in the mosque.

Sites said three other insurgents wounded Friday in the mosque were also shot again Saturday by the Marines.

Basic rule of warfare
International legal experts said protection of injured combatants once they are out of action is a basic rule in warfare but that the Marine shown in the video may have acted in self-defense.

Charles Heyman, a British infantry veteran and senior defense analyst with Jane’s Consultancy Group in London, defended the Marine, saying soldiers are taught that the enemy “is at his most dangerous when he is severely injured.”

Other experts contacted by The Associated Press were careful to avoid a public judgment because of the dangerous and uncertain situation in Fallujah, where U.S. troops were still fighting insurgents.

“It’s clearly recognized that people in combat situations are under enormous strain,” International Red Cross spokesman Florian Westphal said in Geneva. “Obviously, we were not on the spot, so we cannot judge the precise circumstances of what was being shown here.”

Westphal said the Geneva Conventions are clear: Protection of wounded combatants once they are out of action is an absolute requirement.

Status unclear
However, the status of the wounded man was unclear. A different Marine unit had come under fire from the mosque on Friday. Those Marines stormed the building, killing 10 men and wounding five, according to Sites. He said Marines treated the wounded and left them.

The same five men were in the mosque Saturday when Marines from another unit arrived. Westphal said he couldn’t say for sure from NBC’s account whether the man was a prisoner.

Heyman said there is a danger that a wounded enemy may try to detonate a hidden firearm or a grenade, and if the man made the slightest move “in my estimation they would be justified in shooting him.”

However, legal distinctions are unlikely to carry much weight among many Iraqis, especially Sunnis already angry over the Fallujah offensive. Allawi said he ordered the assault after Fallujah’s leaders refused to hand over Jordanian terror mastermind Abu Musab al-Zarqawi and other foreign fighters.

‘I wanted to scream’
But Sunni militants saw the invasion of the city 40 miles west of Baghdad as a plot by the Americans and the Shiites, such as Allawi, against religious Sunnis — an allegation both governments deny.

“The troops not only violated our mosques with their sins and their boots, but they stepped on our brothers’ blood,” said Khalil, the shop owner. “They are criminals and mercenaries. I feel guilty standing here and not doing anything.”

At a news conference Tuesday, Iraqi Interior Minister Falah Hassan al-Naqib, himself a Sunni, said that although “killing a wounded person is rejected by us,” Fallujah militants were “killers and criminals” who committed brutal acts.

That meant little to Hameed Farhan, 51, who works for the Transportation Ministry in Baghdad.

“I did not see it because there was no electricity at home, but my wife was at her parents’ and she described it for me,” Farhan said. “She was crying. Tears welled up in my eyes. I wanted to scream.”

© 2004 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Proud to be an American
Not blind. Not uninformed. We are party to atrocities. But the response of the world after 9/11 is worth noting. Even our most dire enemies offered aid. We should all be so lucky.
Volcana is offline  
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
post #2 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 17th, 2004, 03:34 AM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: sydney
Posts: 6,144
                     
What I found pretty interesting about this is that the footage of the shooting came from an embedded journalist.

The embedded journalists have been criticised for not showign the 'real' story of war and presenting both sides - because they are travelling and living etc with whatever platoon they are assigned to, they generally regurgitate whatever the government/military wants them to - their independance is compromised because they are part of the army unit they are embedded with..

So i found it interesting that this potentially damaging story came from one of the US Media...

Of even more significance, there's this little gap in Graf's resume the size of the hole in the ozone layer: It's called Monica Seles. Was Graf the best female player of all time? She wasn't even the best in the heart of her career.
- Frank Deford, Sports Illustrated 27/8/01
Philbo is offline  
post #3 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 17th, 2004, 04:07 AM Thread Starter
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Posts: 25,078
                     
Quote:
Originally Posted by Czechfan
So i found it interesting that this potentially damaging story came from one of the US Media...
The embedded reporters are in a nasty situation, just like the soldiers. You notice no one tried to stop him from filming (which I expect to change now). That was normal for the current situation. Our troops have been handed a shit job, with insufficient resources. Not that they won't eventually complete conquering Iraq. But most of them know there was no need, and that they were sent without protective equipment that COULD have been made available. In the spring, there were reports of bullet shortages.

And casualty counts are running far ahead of what was anticipated.

It's a shit job, and nobody NEEDED to do it. But thousands aof Americans, and literally hundreds of thousands of Iraqis are paying the price for a conflict that has nothing to do with defending the United States.

Proud to be an American
Not blind. Not uninformed. We are party to atrocities. But the response of the world after 9/11 is worth noting. Even our most dire enemies offered aid. We should all be so lucky.
Volcana is offline  
post #4 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 17th, 2004, 04:25 AM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Posts: 6,896
                     
the people of the United States voted in favor of the Iraq war, 51 percent to 48. The votes of the 56 million people in this country who voted against the Republicans don't mean a god damn thing. I guess that's just democracy in action.
vogus is offline  
post #5 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 17th, 2004, 07:02 AM
pav
Senior Member
 
pav's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: new zealand
Posts: 9,642
                     
It certainly is very easy for the Worlds media to jump on something like this, Al-Jezeera and the like never criticise the militants of Their persuasion for indiscriminately blowing up children etc. but let a U.S. soldier do one thing wrong and they start howling,backed up by sad looking liberal news readers like We have over here. Not many people have been in a situation such as was faced by that soldier,go into a building and some militant who was supposedly dead starts wriggling about ,with those bastards track record ,I'd shoot the bugger too,better to be sure than sorry,those sort of maniac Moslems think it's great to die anyway,so He was doing Him a favour!

If every bugger realised any sort of religion is a load of bullshit the World would be a better place, all that killing over fairy tales
pav is offline  
post #6 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 17th, 2004, 11:25 PM Thread Starter
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Posts: 25,078
                     
Quote:
Originally Posted by vogus
the people of the United States voted in favor of the Iraq war, 51 percent to 48. The votes of the 56 million people in this country who voted against the Republicans don't mean a god damn thing. I guess that's just democracy in action.
The people of the United States didn't voted in favor of the Iraq war. They didn't get any say in it all.

The two choices they were offerred for President offered almost identical plans for dealing with it. If you're calling the last Presidential election a referendum continuing to fight the Iraq war, the American people voted to continue fighting it 99% to 1%.

Proud to be an American
Not blind. Not uninformed. We are party to atrocities. But the response of the world after 9/11 is worth noting. Even our most dire enemies offered aid. We should all be so lucky.
Volcana is offline  
post #7 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 18th, 2004, 12:47 AM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Hitlum
Posts: 8,050
                     
well, I don't feel sorry for terrorists that behead harmless civilians, don't they want to die to go to paradise? he got his wish.
Fingon is offline  
post #8 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 18th, 2004, 12:57 AM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: b/n 1 & 3
Posts: 3,628
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fingon
well, I don't feel sorry for terrorists that behead harmless civilians, don't they want to die to go to paradise? he got his wish.
This person who was shot while wounded - do we know if he killed a civilian? Do we know if beheaded one? Do we know if he wanted to go to paradise? Or are we just working on assumptions and generalizations here?
Hulet is offline  
post #9 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 18th, 2004, 01:01 AM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: USA
Posts: 3,330
                     
US convoy bombed and 10 die.
jbone_0307 is offline  
post #10 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 18th, 2004, 01:48 AM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Hitlum
Posts: 8,050
                     
Quote:
Originally Posted by Psychon
This person who was shot while wounded - do we know if he killed a civilian? Do we know if beheaded one? Do we know if he wanted to go to paradise? Or are we just working on assumptions and generalizations here?
no, we don't, but if he was a terrorist and was fighthing with and for them, he should have known the risks.

The terrorists have tried everything to keep the marines out of fallujah, simply because they are not as brave as they want us to believe, they are against innocent civilians but not against well armed soldiers
Fingon is offline  
post #11 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 18th, 2004, 02:03 AM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: b/n 1 & 3
Posts: 3,628
 
I still don't get this. Are you saying everybody who fought the Americans in Fallujah is a terrorist?
Hulet is offline  
post #12 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 18th, 2004, 02:17 AM Thread Starter
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Posts: 25,078
                     
Quote:
Originally Posted by Psychon
This person who was shot while wounded - do we know if he killed a civilian? Do we know if beheaded one? Do we know if he wanted to go to paradise? Or are we just working on assumptions and generalizations here?
We don't know anything about him except he's dead. Well, I'm sure Fingon knows. And I'm sure he's shared he's thought with Rumsfeld.

Something Bush said a couple months back come to mind. The exact quote escapes me, but it was something to the effect of "The people who are fighting us because they're country's been invaded, they aren't terrorists." I remember being shocked he'd make that distinction. But fortunately, we have Fingon to tell us who's just fighting to repel foreign invaders, and who's beheading civilians.

Proud to be an American
Not blind. Not uninformed. We are party to atrocities. But the response of the world after 9/11 is worth noting. Even our most dire enemies offered aid. We should all be so lucky.
Volcana is offline  
post #13 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 18th, 2004, 02:19 AM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Hitlum
Posts: 8,050
                     
Quote:
Originally Posted by Psychon
I still don't get this. Are you saying everybody who fought the Americans in Fallujah is a terrorist?
pretty much, it's not the iraqui army is it?
Fingon is offline  
post #14 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 18th, 2004, 02:22 AM
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Hitlum
Posts: 8,050
                     
Quote:
Originally Posted by Volcana
We don't know anything about him except he's dead. Well, I'm sure Fingon knows. And I'm sure he's shared he's thought with Rumsfeld.

Something Bush said a couple months back come to mind. The exact quote escapes me, but it was something to the effect of "The people who are fighting us because they're country's been invaded, they aren't terrorists." I remember being shocked he'd make that distinction. But fortunately, we have Fingon to tell us who's just fighting to repel foreign invaders, and who's beheading civilians.
for sure there are a lot of people in Iraq fighting against foreign invaders. The marines are fighting against Jordanians, Syrians, Chechens.

The leader of the "iraqui" resistance is Jordan, and they fight by killing iraquis recruit with a shot in the head.

And, if I had talked to Rumsfeld and he had listened, believe me, it wouldn't be pretty for the terrorists.
Fingon is offline  
post #15 of 26 (permalink) Old Nov 18th, 2004, 02:38 AM
Senior Member
 
Justeenium's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: I paid$$ to get unbanned
Posts: 1,733
                     
Quote:
Originally Posted by vogus
the people of the United States voted in favor of the Iraq war, 51 percent to 48. The votes of the 56 million people in this country who voted against the Republicans don't mean a god damn thing. I guess that's just democracy in action.
wow. what an idiot. If you would actually read, you would know in surveys that slightly more people now say we should not have gone into Iraq.

And a vote for Kerry is not a vote agains the Iraq war dumbass. :retard:
Justeenium is offline  
Reply

Quick Reply
Message:
Options

Register Now



In order to be able to post messages on the TennisForum.com forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.

User Name:
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.

Password:


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:
OR

Log-in









Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.



Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page



Posting Rules  
You may not post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome