i dont think anyone can ever really say both players have played their best it just depends on how you look at it. IE to say venus and davenport wimbledon 05 makes me look at head to heads and think lindsay is quite capable of beating venus, and as she didnt, she obviously didnt play her best tennis.
Obvviously one player will always play better than another ona set day hence why they win a match. gotta rise your game.
<!Game, Set and Match!>