Re: Mixed Doubles R1: Oudin/Sock def. Srebotnik/Zimonjic 4-6, 6-3, [15-13]
Sigh, I'm not saying that she played excellent all the way through, or was the best player out there. The first set was pretty bad, they were both "scratchy" an got better as they played. But, the statement that she "did nothing" throughout the match is just as ridiculous as the idea that she was great all the way through. She made plenty of errors, but she was solid enough when she needed to be, and occasionally hit some great shots. So sure, I "rebel" against the idea she was worthless and did nothing, and the fact that you think "She played an excellent Super" tells me you don't agree with it either.
As for Sock, I'm not over criticizing, I thought he was great on serve and very good from the baseline, but I think he has room to improve at the net. He can get a little over excited. While yes, Mel made mistakes too, I think when she got into exchanges at the net I think she was a bit more purposeful, though she needed to be more dialed in to make them work. Her ideas were good, execution a bit lacking at times. She got better though as the match went on.